The Civilizing Process and the Decline of Violence

THE DEBATE over whether humanity is becoming less violent has its beginnings in Ted Robert Gurr’s 1982 article “Historical trends in violent crime : a critical review of the evidence” (in Tonry and Morris, eds, Crime and Justice : an Annual Review of Research).  Several other studies, mainly based on homicide data from Scandinavia and Holland, appeared to corroborate Gurr’s findings, and pretty soon this pattern of an apparent decline in violence was linked to Norbert Elias’s thesis of a “civilizing process”, first propounded in Über den Prozeß der Zivilisation (1939), but virtually unknown until it was republished in 1969 and translated into English.

Manuel Eisner’s “Long-Term Trends in Violent Crime” (2003) sums up the general findings of the previous couple of decades with the words, “Serious interpersonal violence decreased remarkably in Europe between the mid-sixteenth and the early twentieth centuries” (p. 83), elaborating that, while there may be disagreement about the details and, more fundamentally,  the causes of the decline, the fact of the decline itself is hardly in doubt:

… if nothing else, most historians of crime would probably agree that the long-term trajectory in homicide rates is an indicator of a wider dynamic that encompasses some sort of pacification of interaction in public space. (P. 125)

So far, discussion of the issue is based on various kinds of court records of homicide rates. Steven Pinker, in the following TED presentation (2007) takes the whole issue one step further, arguing that there has been a decline of violence not merely in the civilian context but including the field of warfare:

Specifically, he says that if the hunter-gatherer norms of 10,000+ years ago had been prevalent during the 20th century humanity would seen something like two billion deaths through warfare, rather than the 100 million that actually occurred (3:48-4:06).

This statistic is based on an observation of deaths in warfare in hunter-gather tribes today, which he gives as ranging from nearly 60% among the Jivaro to around 15% among the Gebusi (3:20 ff). One can argue about whether that is the best way to measure the data, but he does give rather more varied data in The Better Angels of our Nature (2011), summed up in the following graph:

violence graph

He modifies his position slightly in the book, saying that tribal warfare was nine times as deadly as war and genocide in the 20th century (“Rates of Violence in State and Non-State Societies”).

One can see where Pinker is going just from the above table; by his reckoning states, even in ancient times, were much safer, less violent places to live than non-state or tribal societies. The rather anecdotal evidence given in the video of violence in biblical times, classical antiquity and the medieval period is also more fully presented in the book than in the video presentation, though he does not fully erase the objection that, just because there were horrific war crimes and cruelty was tolerated in public spaces as a salutary measure and as entertainment, that does not in itself prove that there was quantifiably more violence.

I won’t go into the second half of Pinker’s presentation, where he develops various theories about why violence is declining, because I’d like to slow down a little and think a bit more deeply about the basis for the assumption that violence is declining. How sure can we be that Gurr and Eisner and Pinker – and a string of other researchers in the area – have got it right?

In spite of the virtual consensus that Eisner claims (cited above) the decline of violence may not be quite such a given as it appears to be. Richard Mc Mahon, Joachim Eibach and Randolph Roth, in “Making sense of violence? Reflections on the history of interpersonal violence in Europe” (Crime, Histoire & Sociétés, 17:2, 2013, pp. 5-26), sound a note of caution, pointing out that Pinker may be getting too far ahead of himself in attributing the decline to “individualism, cosmopolitanism, reason, and science” while others are still “preferring … to emphasize changes in medical expertise and practice, in the age structure of the population and also the difficulties inherent in the use of the available sources” (p. 6).

Objections at this level preempt asking what has caused the decline in violence; in effect, they undermine – or at least cast into doubt – the proposition that there has been any decline at all. Here, in detail, are some of the objections:

Historians of homicide are also not always comparing like with like when they compare homicide rates from the middle ages with those of later periods. In an English context … the homicide rates from the early modern period are often derived from the number of indictments for homicide while those for the middle ages are generated from coroners’ rolls … This would suggest that any simple narrative of decline is problematic. The available evidence rather indicates that rates fluctuated considerably between the late middle ages and the early modern period with … no obvious or consistent pattern of decline. There is also a difficulty for those who support the civilising process thesis in drawing on evidence from the fourteenth century without offering due attention to rates from the thirteenth century which indicate that rates at that time were actually lower than a century later. The use of the fourteenth century as a point of comparison can then serve to distort the difference between the middle ages and the early modern period.

… the late sixteenth and early seventeenth century was a time of particularly high rates in many regions. This again distorts the difference between the eighteenth and earlier centuries … [and] suggests any broad narrative of decline driven by a wider civilising process is at least open to question.

… Recent estimates suggest that circa 50 per cent of victims in the late nineteenth century would have survived if they had access to the benefits of modern medical care and emergency services … Might, for instance, individuals in societies that experienced major episodes of famine such as Ireland, Belgium and Finland be more likely to die following violent attacks than those in countries spared the ravages of widespread food shortages ? Remarkably there has, as yet, been no attempt to establish a correlation between homicide rates and broader trends in mortality and health over time and space. Stress and depression are serious health problems, if you suffer any of these this blog post is going to help you a lot.

The impact of medical care and nutrition on homicide rates also has implications for the civilising process thesis. High homicide rates … are usually due to the prevalence of male-on-male fighting [which] must, however, be far less likely to lead to homicide in the present day due to medical intervention and improved nutrition that people do even using diets they find online as in this Rapid tone reviews… there is a lack of intent to kill in the first instance ; … the protagonists are less likely to have pre-planned the attack and are, therefore, less likely to bring weapons to the scene ; and … they are more likely than, for instance, cases of domestic violence to involve protagonists of similar strength. It is likely, therefore, that improvements in medical care would have a particular impact on the extent of homicides arising from male-on-male fighting relative to other forms of homicide.

If we allow for improvements in medical care, the impact of emergency services and improved nutrition, and take account as well of the need to revise the population estimates … we could reasonably argue that medieval homicide rates need to be reduced significantly before they are compared to rates in the present day. If we were to simply allow for improvements in medical care and emergency services, present-day rates could be very similar to rates in the eighteenth century … In some cases the rates for the eighteenth century would be lower than those for the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. Rates for the fourteenth century would still be higher than the European average … today but even here we need to be careful. First, rates calculated for the thirteenth century would be much closer to those in the present – again raising questions about any fundamental decline in experiences of interpersonal violence. Second, and perhaps most crucially, questions can also be asked about the use of homicide rates as an indicator of the extent of non-lethal interpersonal violence. Central to the civilising process thesis is the claim that homicide rates can be seen as indicators of the wider prevalence of violence in a society … This … although ostensibly reasonable, is based more on assumptions rather than on evidence of the relationship between lethal and non-lethal violence. (Mc Mahon, Eibach and Roth, pre-publication proof.)

Mc Mahon, Eibach and Roth conclude that “We need to at least entertain the idea that it is possible for there to be a difference
in homicide rates between different societies and/or periods without this necessarily reflecting a fundamental difference in the extent of non-lethal violence”. They are not saying that it is back to the drawing board on this, but they do seem to be suggesting that people like Max Christoph Roser, who are taking Pinker’s analysis as gospel and making it their starting point for further suppositions along the lines of Elias’s “civilizing process”, may perhaps be jumping the gun.

Acknowledgement: A proof of Mc Mahon, Eibach and Roth's paper was sent to my by John Cronin (European University Institute, Florence alumnus), with the blessings of one of the co-authors (I think Richard McMahon). My thanks to both, and let me take this opportunity of giving a plug to their forthcoming book, which I understand is scheduled for publication in 2016.

Two new books on the history of pain

Continuing my attempt to keep up with research in the field, here are two recent publications in the field of medical humanities.

Rob Boddice (ed.), Pain and Emotion in Modern History  (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014). Chapters by Rob Boddice, Javier Mocoso, Paolo Santangelo, David Biro, Joanna Bourke, Wilfried Witte, Nouémi Tousignant, Sheeny Cully, Liz Gray and Danny Rees (detailed list of contents here).

Both books are also reviewed by Ian Miller.

Medieval Manuscripts: the Crude and the Macabre

I am working on a couple of substantial pieces, which I’ll post in due course. Here are a couple of tidbits in the meantime…

Follow Euan McCartney’s bizarre posts  here.

 [contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Website’ type=’url’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]

Damned if we do! Using the EEBO TCP Database

Can we use the EEBO TCP database?

This looks like a no-brainer – what would be the use of the Early English Books Online Text Creation Partnership if we can’t use it? – but it’s actually something of a minefield. How often, I wonder, has work citing the database been met with a response like the following?

I somewhat distrust the author’s generalizations because several of them appear to come from typing keywords into the Early English Books Online searchable database.

The starting point of any online database research  will  inevitably be typing keywords. If that is wrong in itself then all the money that has been spent on creating databases has clearly been misspent! And any research which does no more than type in keywords and simply report on results is hardly worthy of the name research.

Let’s start by taking a look at an example of a keyword search and the follow-up work it entails:

[This is the third in a series of three videos I posted a few weeks ago on the use of the EEBO and TCP databases. The complete series of videos is here.]

It should be clear from this that searches of this kind are pretty gruelling. Typing in keywords is the starting point, but after that a wide range of variables needs to be taken into account, from variant spellings to differences in the number of books published within a particular genre during a particular period. And, crucially, the process involves checking the results of the searches to ensure that the occurrences really are valid examples of the particular usage one is interested in.

For me, that’s just the starting point, the spadework before getting down to the job of analyzing usage in particular contexts, relating that to source texts (a lot of my work is with translations, so I want to know what the original text said), checking the background and views of authors, placing the usage in the context of other related texts and so on.

I’m a texty kind of guy, so I’m less interested in the statistical stuff than in seeing the results in context, but the raw figures can sometimes be of interest. EEBO TCP is still incomplete, but it nevertheless offers a much bigger – and more representative – sample than, say, a MORI poll, and it is unlikely that the general pattern of discourse usage picked out in the video above will alter very much once the gaps remaining in the database have been filled.

Last summer (2013) I attended a conference on early modern digital humanities. I could have done with that kind of input before embarking on Pain, Pleasure and Perversity; I might have escaped some of the more obvious pitfalls. I only cite the database eight times in 235 pages, and I don’t think the few claims I made based on it are wrong to any substantial degree, but even so I can see, in hindsight, ways I could have tightened up my approach/presentation.

What really interests me, though, is the discovery that, in acknowledging my use of the database, I appear very much to have stuck my neck out.  A search for “EEBO TCP” on Google Books currently purports to turn up some 450 results, though in fact it dries up after page 7, giving fewer than 70 results (does anyone know why this happens on Google?). Astonishingly (to me), my book appears on the first page (at the bottom)! Most of the other books on that first page are specifically on the use of online databases in early modern studies. Can I really be so unusual as a researcher working in the field and giving credit to the database?

Apparently, yes. I searched again, specifying publications since 2010, and there is only one page of results!

So what is actually happening here? Are scholars just not using the database? I don’t think so. The impression I get from talking to people at conferences, etc., is that early modernists are logging in at about the same rate as other people have hot breakfasts. Is this such a recent development that it is not yet fully reflected in print? Probably, to some extent. About three years ago, after I had been working solidly on the database for about three weeks in the Rare Books Room at Cambridge University Library, one of the librarians came up and asked me what I was working on. I showed him the database and he was astounded; Cambridge was affiliated to it, but none of the library staff even knew it existed! A couple of months later they held a seminar on it, but prior to that it seems not to have been on anyone’s radar; I certainly didn’t see anyone else using it.

American scholars appear to have been quicker off the mark. I would frequently notice a marked slowdown in download times in the middle of the afternoon, which would be about the time people in the US would be logging on.

I could be wrong about this, but what it looks like to me is that lots of people are using the database, but not many are acknowledging it. Top marks on that score to Bruce R. Smith (in Christie Carson and Peter Kirwan, eds, Shakespeare and the Digital World: Redefining Scholarship and Practice, CUP, 2014), who writes:

I didn’t even have to rely on my recollections of just where the passages I wanted were located. I could simply enter a keyword as a search term, and there the desired text would be on my computer screen, ready for cutting and pasting directly into my draft …  What effectively connected me to the texts I wanted was not just my possession of a computer but my university’s subscriptions to EEBO and EEBO-TCP. (Pp. 24-5)

Even then, though, Smith’s main point is how he was brought back to the reality of the printed book when one of the texts he wanted to access wasn’t on the database.

Many others, I suspect, are being less than candid about their use of the database. I could have done the same. How smart I would have looked, with all that intimate knowledge of such a wide range of texts!

I’m glad I was up-front about it, though. I would be the first to agree that there is nothing quite like the printed book, and uses of the database that took me away from reading and analyzing text just wouldn’t interest me but, like Smith, the database ‘connected me to the texts I wanted’ (or to many of them), and enabled me to find out things about the early modern printed corpus that simply would not have been discoverable by any other means.

Related posts:


Using the Early English Books Online and Text Creation Partnership Databases

[contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Website’ type=’url’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]

Responding to criticism

To what extent should one respond to criticism of one’s work? Should one respond to it at all? Perhaps one should take a lofty attitude and simply let the critics make of one’s work what they will. Or perhaps one owes it to oneself and to scholarship to clarify things and explain oneself.

I accept, on the whole, the received wisdom on the intentional fallacy, one of the corollaries of which is that authors have only a limited right to assert what their work is about; in a very real sense it is about what readers think it is about. At the same time, there are wrong readings of texts; readers cannot say a text is about x, y or z unless the text in some way supports such a reading. I think that, in this particular case, there may be some benefit in examining specific criticisms of my work and exploring the basis of those criticisms.

So far, there have been three reviews of Pain, Pleasure and Perversity. The first, by Jan Frans van Dijkhuizen, does not leave me with very much to comment on. He has clearly read the book thoroughly, enjoyed it and found the central thesis persuasive. Naturally, I am delighted. Van Dijkhuizen is the author of Pain and Compassion in Early Modern English Literature and Culture (Cambridge: D.S. Brewer, 2012), and is perhaps the one person whose opinion on matters relating to early modern suffering I value above all others. The second, by Leah Marcus, raises a significant issue about what – if anything – we can legitimately expect textual analysis to tell us about the actual world outside the text. And the third, by Thomas Palmer, raises equally significant questions about the intentional fallacy; what can we legitimately infer about the author of a text, and to what extent does it matter?

Responding to reviews could, I realize, be seen as an expression of wounded dignity. I hope that readers will find something else in what I have to say here, something more generally pertinent to texts, the ways in which we engage with them and what we can expect to learn from them.

i) Text and Discourse vis-à-vis Real Life

Marcus begins her review with the words

Yamamoto-Wilson is particularly interested in masochistic elements of religiously induced psychic pain and self-inflicted mortification of the body, which he sees as increasing in seventeenth-century England until a paradigm shift around 1650 caused the language of bodily suffering to migrate to religious Nonconformists, while on the Continent it remained central to Catholic devotion.

I am uncomfortable with pretty much all of this. The statement that I am ‘particularly interested in masochistic elements of religiously induced … pain and … mortification’ contains the entailment that I think ‘religiously induced … pain and … mortification’ have ‘masochistic elements’. This entailment embodies two questionable assumptions, the first being that I think there is a masochistic component to religious suffering and the second being that I think my analysis of religious texts can reveal something about suffering in the world outside the text, in the lives and minds of actual people. I will deal with the second entailment in this section and come back to the first in the following section.

Marcus goes on to say that I see ‘psychic pain and self-inflicted mortification of the body’ as ‘increasing in seventeenth-century England’, but that is not at all what I argue in the book. On the contrary, I am pretty sure that self-inflicted mortification was not on the increase, at least in England, at that time. After all, one of the defining differences between Catholics and Protestants is the general eschewal of penances and mortifications by the latter. As for psychic pain, I really have no idea how much of it there was around, at that time or any other. All I know is that a number of texts, from Burton’s Anatomy of Melancholy to Bunyan’s Grace Abounding, described such pain. The most I can say, on the basis of the textual evidence I examined, is that the urge to suffer did not end with the curtailing of Catholic-style penances, leading to the ‘psychic pain’ that Marcus mentions, and perhaps leading Nonconformists, consciously or unconsciously, to seek out persecution.

Nor do I argue, as Marcus asserts, that ‘a paradigm shift around 1650 caused the language of bodily suffering to migrate to religious Nonconformists, while on the Continent it remained central to Catholic devotion.’ What I actually claim is not that the Nonconformists appropriated ‘the language of bodily suffering’ in general, but that they discoursed more on the specific theme of rejoicing to suffer. I don’t have much to say at all about what was transpiring on the Continent, which is outside my remit.

In any case, all this is only a side issue. It’s not my central thesis, which is that to a considerable extent the eroticization of suffering develops discursively from Protestant reactions to Catholic representations of suffering. Marcus doesn’t mention this at any point in her review.

But my gripe is not just that Marcus gives a garbled version of one of my secondary points, rather than explaining the central thesis of my work. There’s something more fundamentally wrong with the way she is approaching my work. She represents me as quantifying actual levels of psychic pain and self-inflicted mortification, and then goes on to deny that any such inferences can result from textual analysis, saying that ‘print culture does not necessarily represent culture at large’. She’s certainly got that last part right; print culture does not have any necessary bearing on what is going on in the culture at large. But she’s quite wrong in assuming that I have anything very much to say about what is going on in the culture at large.

The subject matter of my book is not suffering but discourses of suffering. Discourse is discourse. Analysis of discourse is analysis of discourse. It may bear some relationship to the world outside the text. It may not. I make no claims that it does, at least when it comes to the extent to which objective suffering was going on in seventeenth-century English society. That is not my concern, by which I don’t mean that I’m not interested in it or don’t care about it, simply that it lies outside the scope of discourse/textual analysis. Of course, I sometimes find it appropriate to place texts in their cultural context, but anyone approaching the book expecting it to quantify levels of actual suffering during the seventeenth century is looking for something that just isn’t there.

ii) My Views vis-à-vis the Views Expressed in the Texts I Examine

Palmer gives a much better overview than Marcus of the aims of my book:

The author aims to demonstrate that, … in seventeenth-century England, a discursive space opened up in which sadism and masochism could be more fully articulated as ‘sexual identities’ (p. 6 f.). The Protestant reaction away from the perceived excesses of the Catholic penitential ethic … helped to establish two preconditions for the emergence of a ‘pornography of pain’. As the dimensions of legitimate and praiseworthy suffering were contracted, the sphere of the taboo and the titillating was enlarged; while the polemical association of penitential corporal chastisements with those from which the perceived sexual deviant derives gratification rendered explicit the connection between physical suffering and sexual pleasure. So sadism and masochism could emerge avant la lettre. But, argues the author, this was the result of a complex interaction between the two ‘discourse communities’ entrenched in Europe by the Reformation, Protestant writing in English being coloured by the material it sought to repudiate, and Catholic works translated for an English audience limited by the criteria of acceptability operative in English ‘discourse’.

Despite this very clear summary, Palmer doesn’t really have anything positive to say about my work, unless one counts his comment that it ‘composes a colourful impression of the violent and the visceral, the ribald and the salacious in the seventeenth-century mentality’ as being positive. At the end of the review he picks me up on a couple of matters of fact, saying these are ‘relatively venial sins’, the implication apparently being that I committed a mortal sin by writing the book at all!

Palmer makes it very clear why he feels like this; the main reason is because he takes my ‘major interpretative principle’ to be that ‘the ascetic value ascribed to suffering in Christian thought and practice may be understood as the expression of masochistic or sadistic tendencies’. So far, so good; certainly, Christian suffering ‘may be understood’ in that way. But when he moves from the passive into active mode and says that I personally ‘inevitably [see] the religious attitude to suffering and self-mortification as evidence of perversity’ then he crosses a line, the same line that Marcus crosses (though less definitively) when she represents me as saying that ‘religiously induced … pain and … mortification’ have ‘masochistic elements’.

Marcus does not develop this point, but Palmer makes it central to his analysis. As far as I am concerned it is quite wrong. When writing the book, I attempted to keep my own views out of it as far as possible and simply report on what emerged from an analysis of the texts. For the record, though, I spent a number of years living in Spain, and not only observed penitential practices at first hand (particularly, of course, at Easter) but counted a fair sprinkling of penitentes among my friends. I can categorically say that I never had the slightest suspicion that there was anything in the least bit ‘kinky’ in what they were doing; they approached the whole issue in an extraordinarily serious and heartfelt way, and I have no doubt of their sincerity. On the other hand, if anybody’s asking, yes, I do think there’s something a bit weird about the nun who was ‘wont to drawe herself along vpon the ground, holding by a rope which she put about her neck, and whipping herself with a chayne’, all the while chiding her ‘miserable body’ (Antonio Daza, The Historie of the Blessed Virgin, Sister Ioane, of the Crosse, 1625, cited in the book on page 67).

So I don’t ‘inevitably’ think that religious suffering is masochistic, although there are moments when I have to wonder. But this is all beside the point. The aim of the book is to trace the way in which masochistic readings of accounts of religious suffering developed, not to ascertain whether such suffering is or is not in itself masochistic. This is a vital distinction, and failure to make it is going to give any reader a distorted impression of what the book is all about.

The point is not that ‘the religious attitude to suffering and self-mortification [is] evidence of perversity’. The point is that sadomasochistic discourse arose, in part, because anti-Catholic discourse came, increasingly, to represent Catholic asceticism as the expression of perverse tendencies. The point is not whether Magdalena de Pazzi got a sexual kick out her practices. She may have done, she may not. I have no way of knowing. The point is that a Catholic owner of the 1619 translation of her biography wrote on the flyleaf ‘O that mine adversary had written a book!’ In other words, even an English Catholic could see that a work of this kind would merely reinforce the prejudices of the English Protestant reader. The point is not whether Jerome got an erection while writing about a Christian martyr who, tied to a bed, taunted and sexually aroused by a prostitute, bites off his tongue and spits it in her face just as she mounts him and bends down to kiss him. The point is that this passage is heavily censored in early modern Protestant translations, while Catholic translations retain far more of the erotic detail of the original. It’s a difference in discourse. It’s got nothing to do with what I personally believe or disbelieve.

Palmer takes particular exception to my discussion of Bunyan, much of which actually defends Bunyan against the charge of masochism, arguing that, within the terms of what he believes to be the nature of his life on earth, his response is perfectly sane and normal, but which I conclude by saying that there is an apparent obsession with suffering in Bunyan that goes beyond the exigencies of the religio-political context, and which ‘we can hardly scruple to call masochistic’. A summary of my comments on Bunyan is posted here.

I accept that I go further in commenting on Bunyan the person than is my usual practice in the book, but I am working in the context of modern critical responses. The observation that Bunyan has a ‘habit of expressing psychic states through images of bodily abuse’ is not mine. I cite it from John Knott, Discourses of Martyrdom in English Literature (1993). The designation of Bunyan’s propensity to take ‘revengement upon my self ’ as part of a ‘masochistic economy of … spirituality’ is not mine. I cite it from Lori Branch, Rituals of Spontaneity: Sentiment and Secularism from Free Prayer to Wordsworth (2006). And there are others.

I can hardly discuss perverse attitudes towards suffering in early modern England without taking on board reactions such as these. My point is not that suffering was what floated Bunyan’s boat, and if I were asked did I think Bunyan gained sexual satisfaction either through suffering or through writing about it I would have to say that I think it extremely unlikely. As ever, though, that line of questioning is irrelevant. What matters is that Bunyan is discursively obsessed with suffering, that there are aspects of his writings which closely correspond with the core sense of the word masochism as we use it today, and that therefore it seems not unreasonable that critics should apply that term.


There is a certain irony in all this; in accusing me of making false assumptions about the people behind hagiographic and devotional texts Palmer makes false assumptions about me.

I began by saying that authors have only a limited right to say what their work is about, and that, in a very real sense, texts are about what readers think they are about. If Protestant readers thought that Catholic hagiography was really about people getting sexual satisfaction from their suffering then that would be, to all intents and purposes, what it was about. But anti-Catholic polemic is not based on an assumption that the biographers of the saints were intentionally writing about people getting sexual satisfaction from suffering; they knew that by drawing that inference from the text they were interpreting the text in a way that the author of the text would not only have been unaware of but, if confronted with it, would have vigorously denied the validity of.

The anti-Catholic polemicists were acting mischievously, knowing that they were ascribing features to texts that the authors of those texts would have rejected. Palmer, by contrast, identifies what he plainly thinks are my true intentions. He thinks the whole book is an attempt to place religious experience on a par with sadomasochistic fantasy.

So what’s really going on here? Do I just think I wrote a book about how Protestant polemic recast Catholic accounts of suffering as thinly-veiled pornography, when what I in fact wrote was a book about how I personally think that Catholic suffering (or, indeed, Christian suffering in general) was thinly-veiled pornography all along, and all Protestants did was take off the veil?

I don’t think I can answer that question. Readers have to be left to make up their own minds about that sort of thing. Equally, it is readers, and not I, who must determine whether I only imagine that I wrote a book that says something significant about the discursive eroticization of suffering in seventeenth-century England, when what I in fact wrote was a book that fails to say anything persuasive about actual suffering in seventeenth-century England.

Marcus was faced with the unenviable task of reviewing all the full-length works in the field that had appeared over the previous year. It is only to be expected that there will be moments when it is apparent that she is not as intimate with the contents of all these works as one might ideally wish her to be. If she didn’t pick out my central thesis perhaps I was at fault for not sufficiently emphasizing it. Perhaps a similar reason lies at the root of her  supposition that I have written about actual levels of psychic suffering and self-inflicted mortification when to me it is clear that I am writing, not about these things themselves, but about the ways in which people discoursed on them. At least I know she appreciated some parts of my analysis; she cites my discussion of early modern translations of St. Jerome’s account of Saint Paul the Hermit as an example of one of the ‘fascinating tidbits’ she found in the work.

Palmer has clearly gone over my work sufficiently thoroughly to be able to summarize the main arguments. As a theologian he finds that my ‘confessional categories appear crude’, and he may be right about this. I know the book isn’t perfect, and I would certainly value some detailed commentary on this aspect of it. I think he has fallen prey doubly to a kind of intentional fallacy, firstly by attributing to me a belief that religious suffering is masochistic and secondly by thinking that my views on that point make any difference to the validity or otherwise of the analysis, but that is really a matter for others to judge. I do hope it is not the case that the entire concept is a mortal sin; I just wanted to write a book – I don’t want to burn in hell for it!

I knew when I wrote it that the book was likely to be controversial. Even if I feel Marcus and Palmer have got me wrong or that they are making the wrong kinds of assumptions about what can validly be inferred, not just from my work, but from texts in general, they have both taken the trouble to put some time into reading what I wrote and expressing their response to it, and I am grateful to them for that.


[contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Website’ type=’url’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]

Using the Early English Books Online and Text Creation Partnership Databases

(This post contains the substance of a presentation I gave at the Annual Conference of the Shakespeare Society of Japan in October, 2014.)

For those who are not familiar, here is an introduction to the use of the Early English Books Online database (EEBO):

EEBO requires a log-in, but many – if not most – universities subscribe to the database and access can be gained through them. Another way to gain access is by joining the Renaissance Society of America, which includes access to EEBO in the membership package.

EEBO gives access to PDF files of early modern books. These files are not text-searchable. The Text Creation Programme (EEBO TCP) gives access in a text-searchable form, and its use is explained, using the public access portion of Eighteenth Century Collections Online (ECCO) here:

The following is an example of the kinds of methods that can be used to incorporate searches on the database into an early modern studies research programme:

These videos were made in October 2014, and part of the TCP database came into the public domain in January 2015. This means that there is now public access to some 25,000 early modern texts in text-searchable form. The text-searchable files do not correlate with PDFs in the way the files viewable by subscription do, and there is the rather serious disadvantage that numbering is not given for books numbered by signature rather than by page. But, provided one has access to the PDFs through the EEBO database, one can work around this, and it is still a valuable resource.

Related posts:

Damned if we do! Using the EEBO TCP database


[contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Website’ type=’url’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]


Protestant Reception of Catholic Literature


This is a PowerPoint presentation I made at the Reformation Studies Colloquium, Edmund Murray College, University of Cambridge, September 12th, 2014. It contains the gist of two recently-published papers, “The Protestant Reception of Catholic Devotional Literature in England to 1700” (Recusant History, Vol. 32, No. 1 (2014), pp. 67-89), and “Robert Persons’s Resolution (1582) and the issue of textual piracy in Protestant editions of Catholic devotional literature” (Reformation and Renaissance Review, Vol. 15, No. 2, 2013, pp. 177-98). It’s a bit off the topic of early modern suffering, but it was from a study of the differences between Catholic and Protestant discourse that the work on suffering had its beginnings.

Torture and the Art of Holy Dying

[For this post I am indebted to Olivia Weisser who, in response to my post on The Sufferings of the Martyrs and the Transgressive Female Gaze, very kindly sent me an extract from her dissertation, Gender and Illness in Early Modern England (John Hopkins, 2010), which she is currently working up for publication with Yale University Press in 2015 as Ill Composed: Sickness, Gender, and Belief in Early Modern England. I would like to take this opportunity of thanking her, as well as expressing my appreciation of the insights her work has given me.]


John Donne’s poem illustrates the ideal early modern death as a peaceful process, in which the sick person passed almost imperceptibly from life to death, without “tear-floods” or “sigh-tempests”. This attitude towards death underlies the entire early modern attitude towards illness. As Olivia Weisser puts it:

Pious patients struggled to withstand pain without displaying fear or despair. Complaints were admissible, but only if they exuded patience and hope.

Weisser points out that the bottom line was the belief that God “was the ultimate source of all afflictions”, and cites Jeremy Taylor’s The Rule and Exercises of Holy Dying (1651) as a typical example of early modern attitudes:

…he that is afraid of pain is afraid of his own nature; and if his fear be violent, it is a sign his Patience is none at all; and an impatient person is not ready dressed for Heaven. (P. 124; online text here.)

At first sight, all this calm patience in the face of suffering would seem to be a far cry from what we may suppose to be the experience of and response to torture, but Weisser establishes a close discursive link between patient forbearance in the face of secular suffering – particularly illness and the pains of childbirth – and the sufferings of the martyrs, in which torture played a frequent part:

…torture became a lasting model of suffering well into the 1600s. John Foxe’s sensational account of the persecution of Protestant martyrs under the Catholic Mary Tudor, a book popularly known as the Book of Martyrs, was integral to developing and popularizing this discourse.

Alice Thornton, for example, says of her fifth pregnancy, in 1657:

I was upon the racke in bearing my childe with such exquisitt torment as if each lime weare divided from other, for the space of two houers. (The Autobiography of Mrs. Alice Thornton of East Newton, Co. York, 1875, p. 95.)

Weisser – drawing on Sharon Howard’s ‘Imagining the Pain and Peril of Seventeenth-Century Childbirth: Travail and Deliverance in the Making of an Early Modern World’ (Social History of Medicine, 16:3, 2003, pp. 367-82) – comments:

Comparing her pain to torture highlighted the intensity of her suffering, as well as the spiritual significance of her deliverance from danger. Thornton’s pain, like that of a martyr, was harsh and harrowing, and surviving such an ordeal conveyed God’s profound grace and mercy. Part of the metaphor’s power also lay in the overlapping imagery of a body split on the rack and a body torn apart in childbirth. The discourse of martyrdom gave deep and positive meaning to the spiritual, as well as physical, experience of suffering.


Martyrdom offered scripts for expressing the torments of pain, as well as models of heroic endurance.This is the second way patients employed the discourse of martyrdom: in imitation of martyrs themselves.

The Stoicism of the early modern martyrs, Weisser argues, derives from the late medieval conception of pain as having its origin “in the soul while the body served merely as a vehicle for its expression”:

Just as Protestant sufferers viewed illness as an impediment to overcome in order to pray and meditate, Foxe’s martyrs exhibited a remarkable ability to transcend the corporeal.

Taylor writes elsewhere in Holy Dying about the “supervening necessity” of suffering:

Nothing is intolerable that is necessary … tie the man down to it and he endures it. Now God hath bound this sicknesse upon thee by the condition of Nature … it is also bound upon thee by speciall providence, and with a designe to try thee, and with purposes to reward and crown thee. These cords thou canst not break; and therefore lie thee down gently, and suffer the hand of God to do what he please, that at least thou mayest swallow an advantage, which the care and severe mercies of God forces down thy throat.

Remember that all men have passed this way, the bravest, the wisest, & the best men, have bin subject to sicknes & sad diseases … and under so great, and so universal precedents, so common fate of men, he that will not suffer his portion, deserves to be something else than a man, but nothing that is better. (Pp. 94-5; online text here.)

I have written in another post about how this Stoical view of suffering was so deeply ingrained in the seventeenth-century mindset that any challenge to it was perceived as potentially seditious, and I’ve also posted in praise of Melissa Sanchez, whose Erotic Subjects: The Sexuality of Politics in Early Modern English Literature (OUP, 2011) explores the political ramifications of a kind of institutionalized culture of suffering, in which ‘Agony and abjection’ are given positive meanings as ‘signs of a power that reconfigures traditional definitions of heroism and masculinity’, and ‘Subjects know that they are being abused, but they tolerate affliction because they enjoy the moral authority it gives them’ (pp. 17 and 240). Rejoicing to suffer for Christ and enjoying the moral authority of being an afflicted subject are essentially the same thing; as Pomfret puts it, in the context of the Rye House Plot of 1683:

That man only is Christianly patient, that … is chearful in it; does not only quietly and serenely suffer wrong, but rejoyces in it. This [is] the true Martyrs patience. (Thomas Pomfret, Passive Obedience, Stated and Asserted, London, 1683, p. 8.)

Weisser, however, is primarily interested in what this culture of suffering meant at an individual, rather than a political level.

Calm composure and pious speech in life’s final moments were key signifiers of salvation. Attempts to die in this ideal way were epitomized by sufferers who experienced agonizing pain in the throes of death but remained insensible to the torments.

“These individuals,” she stresses, “were not ascetics or martyrs, but ordinary individuals”, able to overcome their pain by “concentrat[ing] on the afterlife”. Nor, crucially, were they in a state of unconsciousness or insensibility:

The model death in early modern England entailed stoic endurance of pain and a lucid mind. Witnesses at the deathbed reassured absent friends and family that the dying experienced an awakened state in their final moments.

This insistence that the dying person be both conscious of their agonies and patiently accepting of them is at the core of the early modern “art of suffering”, which is the title of Ann Thompson’s book on Puritan attitudes to suffering in the seventeenth century, and which I have written a few comments on here. Thompson focuses on only a narrow range of writers, and analyzes the way in which their approach to the subject of suffering and death was deconstructed by the advance of “anti-providential thought” during the seventeenth century. She notes that, by the later part of the century, Puritan treatises on suffering deal rather with pain management than with the concept of spiritual growth or development through suffering, What Weisser and Sanchez and, I think, my own work demonstrate is that the decline of faith in God’s providence – and a concomitant rejection of the concept of the inevitability, necessity and utility of suffering – can be observed across across a much wider spectrum of writings, opening the way, philosophically, to widespread acceptance of the pleasure principle – the Epicurean idea that it is both natural and right to avoid suffering – as an approach to life, and leading to a society sanitized of suffering by antibiotics, distanced from it by television cameras, toying with it as a means to achieving short-term objectives in sports and sadomasochistic role play, but largely incapable even of imagining the role it played in the lives of people like John Donne or Jeremy Taylor. [contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Website’ type=’url’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]

Two Recent Books on Gender and Violence in the Early Modern Period


1. Jennifer Feather and Catherine E. Thomas, eds., Violent Masculinities: Male Aggression in Early Modern Texts and Culture (Palgrave Macmillan, 2013).

As the blurb has it, “During the early modern period in England, social expectations for men came under extreme pressure; the armed knight went into decline and humanism appeared. Here, original essays analyze a wide-range of violent acts in early modern literature and culture from a rewrite my essay service – everything from civic violence to chivalric combat; from verbal attacks to masochistic suffering; from political assassination to personal retaliation; and from brawls to battles. In so doing, they interrogate the seemingly inevitable connection between masculinity and aggression, placing it in a specific historical context and showing how differences of status, ethnicity, and sexual identity inform masculine ideals.”

The table of contents:

Introduction: Reclaiming Violent Masculinities; Jennifer Feather and Catherine E. Thomas

1. Militant Prologues, Memory, and Models of Masculinity in Shakespeare’s Henry V and Troilus and Cressida; Susan Harlan
2. Marlowe’s War Horses: Cyborgs, Soldiers and Queer Companions; Timothy Francisco
3. Cutting Words and Healing Wounds: Friendship and Violence in Early Modern Drama; Jennifer Forsyth

4. Virtus, Vulnerability, and the Emblazoned Male Body in Shakespeare’s Coriolanus; Lisa S. Starks-Estes
5. Priestly Rulers, Male Subjects: Swords and Courts in Papal Rome; Laurie Nussdorfer
6. ‘Warring Spirits’: Martial Heroism and Anxious Masculinity in Milton’s Paradise Lost; Katharine Cleland

7. King Lear’s Violent Grief; Andrew D. McCarthy
8. Wild Civility: Men at War in Royalist Elegy; Catharine Gray
9. Occupy Macbeth: Masculinity and Political Masochism in Macbeth; Amanda Bailey
10. Melancholy and Spleen: Models of English Masculinity in The Famous History of the Life and Death of Captain Thomas Stukeley; Laurie Ellinghausen

Afterword; Coppélia Kahn

I’ve only just started turning the pages of this, and I’m not going to attempt a review of it yet! So far, my eye has been particularly drawn to Amanda Bailey’s essay on Macbeth, with its discussion of the parallels between rape and demonic possession, and the phenomenon of “a body politic unable to distinguish between coercion and consent” (202), which neatly puts its finger on the essence of the early modern attitude towards rape.

I say a fair bit about this topic in my monograph, citing Juan Luis Vives’s opinion that it was impossible for a virtuous woman to be raped (she must have consented at some level, or the rape could not have occurred), and noting the kind of logic that argued that, since this world is God’s creation, and God would not allow innocents to suffer unduly, rape victims – like witches – must, at some level, be guilty (p. 170).  I just love Aphra Behn’s response to that way of thinking; she says (in the context of forced marriage):

‘ … curse on your nonsense, ye imposing Gownmen, curse on your holy cant; you may as well call Rapes and Murthers, Treason and Robbery, the acts of Heaven; because Heaven suffers ’em to be committed, is it Heavens pleasure therefore, Heaven’s decree? (Love-Letters between a Noble-Man and his Sister, London, 1684, pp. 334–5)

Bailey’s essay seems to be very much in the same ballpark as my own work, as do several of the other papers. Suffice to say that I think there’s going to be a lot for me to chew on in this volume of essays…

2. Mary R. Wade, ed., Gender Matters: Discourses of Violence in Early Modern Literature and the Arts (Editions Rodopi, 2014)


Blurb:”Gender Matters opens the debate concerning violence in literature and the arts beyond a single national tradition and engages with multivalent aspects of both female and male gender constructs, mapping them onto depictions of violence. By defining a tight thematic focus and yet offering a broad disciplinary scope for inquiry, the present volume brings together a wide range of scholarly papers investigating a cohesive topic-gendered violence-from the perspectives of French, German, Italian, Spanish, English, and Japanese literature, history, musicology, art history, and cultural studies. It interrogates the intersection of gender and violence in the early modern period, cutting across national traditions, genres, media, and disciplines. By engaging several levels of discourse, the volume advances a holistic approach to understanding gendered violence in the early modern world. The convergence of discourses concerning literature, the arts, emerging print technologies, social and legal norms, and textual and visual practices leverages a more complex understanding of gender in this period. Through the unifying lens of gender and violence the contributions to this volume comprehensively address a wide scope of diverse issues, approaches, and geographies from late medieval Japan to the European Enlightenment. While the majority of essays focus on early modern Europe, they are broadly contextualized and informed by integrated critical approaches pertaining to issues of violence and gender.”

The Table of Contents:

Mara R. Wade: Introduction Gender Matters: Discourses of Violence in Early Modern Literature and the Arts

Women Warriors, Fact and Fiction
Judith P. Aikin: The Militant Countesses of Rudolstadt: When an unruly army stops by on its way through, it’s time to call on a woman for help.
Elizabeth Oyler: The Woman Warrior Tomoe in Medieval and Early Modern Japanese No Plays
Violent Women, Violated Men
Helmut Puff: Violence, Victimhood, Artistry: Albrecht Dürer’s The Death of Orpheus
Helen Watanabe-O’Kelly: The Eroticization of Judith in Early Modern German Art
Julie Singer: For Palle and Patrie: Re-gendering Violence from Benedetto Varchi to Marguerite de Navarre
Marcus Keller: Framing Men: Violent Women in Marguerite de Navarre’s Heptameron
Violence and the Gendered Body Politic
Catharine Gray: Tears of the Muses: 1649 and the Lost Political Bodies of Royalist War Elegy
Brian Sandberg: Calm Possessor of his Wife, but Not of her Château: Gendered Religious Violence in the French Wars of Religion
Lori Humphrey Newcomb: The Law Against Lovers: Dramatizing Civil Union in Restoration England
Gender in Print
Elizabeth Black: One Gender in the Legal System? An Examination of Gender in a Trio of Emblems from Pierre Coustau’s Pegme (1560)
Tara L. Lyons: Prayer Books and Illicit Female Desires on the Early Modern English Stage
Gerhild Scholz Williams: Romancing the News: History and Romance in Eberhard Happel’s Deß Teutschen Carls (1690) and Deß Engelländischen Eduards (1691)
Gender and Violence on the Stage
Susan Parisi: Transforming a Classical Myth in Seventeenth-Century Opera: the Story of Cybele and Atys in the Libretti of Francesco Rasi and Philippe Quinault
Curtis Perry: Gismond of Salern and the Elizabethan Politics of Senecan Drama
Elizabeth Zeman Kolkovich: “Drabs of State vext”: Violent Female Masquers in Thomas Middleton’s Women Beware Women

Virtue and Violence
Carmen Ripollés: Death, Femininity, and the Art of Painting in Frans Francken’s The Painter’s Studio
Lisa Rosenthal: Masculine Virtue in the Kunstkamer: Pictura, Lucre, and Luxury
Anne J. Cruz: The Walled-In Woman in Medieval and Early Modern Spain
Carl Niekerk: Violence, Gender, and the Construction of the Other in the Story of Inkle and Yarico

Whereas Violent Masculinities, in its broader lines, insists on the gendering of violence as intrinsically masculine, this work takes in a candid look at female-engendered violence.  Again, I’m not yet in a position to give an opinion about the whole book, so I’ll just focus on the second section (“Violent Women, Violated Men”). My attention is drawn naturally to this section, since it has obvious affinities with the final two chapters of my own work (“The Erotics of Suffering and Cruelty” and “The Emergence of the Dominatrix”). I’ll have to admit, I was a bit disappointed to see no references to Melissa Sanchez‘s work, since for my money she’s given the most articulate and persuasive account of masculine submissiveness and anxiety in the early modern period, but there are some significant insights, starting with a chapter by Helmut Puff onAlbrecht Dürer’s Death of Orpheus.

Puff interprets the work in the light of the accompanying scroll, which describes Orpheus as “der Erst Puseran” (“the first bugger”), and “the interest Dürer harboured in scenes of gendered tensions and sexualized violence”, which had “much appeal for the young  Dürer” (p. 74). I posted some stuff a while back on possible obscene imagery in Dürer‘s work, which may be of interest in this context.

The essay that came closest to my own concerns, though, was Marcus Keller’s “Framing Men: Violent Women in Marguerite de Navarre’s Heptameron“, which does for that work much the same as I set out do for Mary Wroth’s Urania – that is, to point out that, while there has been much comment on the violence depicted against women, “women as the source of violence, on the other hand, have received close to no attention” (p. 119). From Keller’s account, such depictions are fairly limited in scope compared with those in Wroth, which cover a wide range of situations, involving both women who are judged by Wroth as evil and others whose actions are exonerated by her.  Navarre confines herself mainly to discoursing on the theme made famous by Congreve (“Heaven has no rage like love to hatred turned, Nor hell a fury like a woman scorned”), but she also apparently discourses on the subject of women who cuckold and betray their men. It was Wroth’s portrayal of the cuckold Sirelius and his violent father-in-law that led to accusations that her work was a thinly-veiled slander of real people (Lord James Hay and Edward Denny, Baron of Waltham, who recognized himself and made the accusation), leading to the withdrawal of the first part of the Urania from publication. Although, in the case of Sirelius, the focus is on male violence, female faithlessness often lay at the heart of misogynistic portrayals of women as the source of all evil, which is essentially the purpose of Simontault, the “sexually … aggressive” narrator of Navarre’s tale, in which the cuckolding wife eggs her weak husband on to instigate a murder.

I’m sure both books contain far more insights than I have been able to mention here, and look forward to perusing them at greater length during the summer vacation!

[contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Website’ type=’url’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]

Masochism in Political Behaviour

A few months ago I commented on Jeremy Carrette’s essay, ‘Intense Exchange: Sadomasochism, Theology and the Politics of Late Capitalism’, expressing frustration at the way in which the author speaks of the need to ‘free our gendered bodies from the market of global exploitation’, but refuses to commit himself to identifying sadomasochism either as part of the problem or as part of the solution. It might be supposed, then, that I would feel much more comfortable with Filip Kovacevic, ‘Masochism in Political Behavior: A Lacanian Perspective’ (2011). And yet, despite the fact that Kovacevic makes it perfectly explicit that, in his view, ‘masochism is a part of the problem and not the solution’, I found his thesis so unsatisfactory that, by the end, I felt positively well-disposed towards Carrette, whose ambivalence at least gives tacit recognition to the imperfectness of the fit between masochistic tendencies and political achievement. By contrast, Kavacevic’s equation of any kind of voluntary-undertaken suffering – from the sufferings of Christ to hunger strikers and suicide bombers – with masochism seems to me to be a distorted oversimplification.

Not that Kavacevic doesn’t hit the nail on the head now and again. Some of what he says about the vicious cycle of political protest and reform rings true, as when he says of a miners’ strike in Montenegro that the miners’ intention ‘was not to effect permanent and lasting changes in their position toward the Other who confronted them, but only to create “enough” anxiety in the Other so that [Prime Minister Djukanovic´] would resolve this particular situation’. A few weeks later, when Djukanovic´ ‘did not fulfill all that he promised’, the cycle repeated itself, and ‘the miners took it out on themselves again’. In this way, through a process of, on the one hand, gratifying and on the other of producing anxiety in the ‘Other’, ‘the masochistic relation will be reasserted, condemning the masochist to constant repetition and the Other’s enjoyment is re-established as a trap from which the masochist can never (quite) escape’.

The way out of this endless cycle, Kavacevic argues, is for the oppressed to ‘move from being the objects of the Other’s enjoyment to being the objects of the Other’s desire’. He sees a neurotic / hysteric response as being superior to a masochistic one;  ‘hysterics, positioning themselves as objects of the Other’s desire, reveal the fact that the dominating Other is lacking and this is exactly what allows them to push for the construction of less oppressive, tolerant Others’.

Having made it clear that he regards Christ and Christianity as doing more harm than good, Kavacevic holds up Socrates as a positive role model, homing in on Socrates’s ironic call on the state of Athens ‘to provide him with life-long honors, while he was being condemned to death’. ‘Masochists’, he says, ‘cannot be ironic’, concluding:

conveying the irony of their situation to hunger-strikers (and suicide bombers) is the only way to help them begin their subjective transformation. Stated in Lacanian terms, masochists position themselves to serve as instruments of enjoyment to a non-existent Other. What could be more absurd and open to ironic interpretation than that?

This does, I admit, give me food for thought, but I am really not sure that there is any real way to distinguish between the ironic sufferer and the masochistic one. I can see that appealing to the Other through self-inflicted suffering is a weaker option than working through the Other’s desire/need for approval, but I’m not even quite sure that this is what Kavacevic is saying.

In short, yet another thought-provoking article that ultimately fails to completely satisfy!

[contact-form][contact-field label=’Name’ type=’name’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Email’ type=’email’ required=’1’/][contact-field label=’Website’ type=’url’/][contact-field label=’Comment’ type=’textarea’ required=’1’/][/contact-form]

The Sufferings of the Martyrs and the Transgressive Female Gaze

Sharon Howard, ‘Imagining the Pain and Peril of Seventeenth Century Childbirth: Travail and Deliverance in the Making of an Early Modern World’, Social History of Medicine, 16:3 (2003), pp. 367-382, is one of those articles that appeared some years ago, but which I have only just come across. (The link, by the way, is to an open-access final proof of the article; to see it in published form log into Oxford Journals.) Hannah Newton, ‘”Very Sore Nights and Days”: The Child’s Experience of Illness in Early Modern England, c. 1580–1720’, Medical History, (2011), pp 153-182, picks up on a point made by Howard, saying, ‘According to Sharon Howard, seventeenth-century lay-people probably learned of torture not from the judicial system, but from the literature of Christian martyrdom’ (Newton, p. 163, referring to Howard, pp. 374-5 [p. 11 of the proof]).

[Three midwives attending to a pregnant woman Jakob
Rueff, ca.1500-1558]


Howard cites Alice Thornton’s account of childbirth:

Make this fire of affliction instrumentall to purge the drosse of all my sinns of negligencys, ignorances, and willfull transgressions, that I may come out like gold out of the furnish.

The Autobiography of Mrs Alice Thornton of East Newton, Co.York, ed. by C. Jackson (Surtees Society, Edinburgh, 1875), p. 90.
The extent to which both men and women identified with suffering martyrs is one of the recurrent themes of my research, so naturally this account piques my interest. Newton notes that children, too, would liken their sufferings during illness to those of the martyrs:


…twelve-year-old Charles Bridgman in 1632 … when considering his pains … ‘called to mind that Martyr Thomas Bilney’, who had burned his own finger in a candle to give himself a taste of what it would be like to burn at the stake.64 Girls as well as boys mentioned martyrs in this way. Fourteen-year-old Mary Glover compared herself to her grandfather, who died a martyr, by repeating his dying words, ‘The comforter is come. O Lord, you have delivered me’. (P. 163)

Of course, as Newton goes on to say, those in pain could see their sufferings either in terms of the redemptive suffering of the martyr, or as a foretaste of the sufferings of the damned. And a third major factor in the way early moderns may have conceptualized their pain ‘in the context of possession’, with its belief in”familiar spirits” …. [which] were animal-shaped evil spirits used by witches to harm or possess their victims’ (p. 165). Newton cites Keith Thomas, Religion and the Decline of Magic 1971, repr. London: Penguin, 1991, p. 566, for the view that children were particularly likely to have recourse to such imagery.


What I want to try and find out more about is the response, particularly of women, to the depictions of suffering in works such as Foxe’s Book of Martyrs, not when they were ill or experiencing the pangs of childbirth, but when they were in a state of health where they were experiencing pain, although after childbirth some women like to get a cosmetic surgery or a SkinMD laser hair removal to improve their appearance.

They finally got treated after finding the right pain clinic in the Opioid News. I’m interested in evidence of women identifying transgressively or subversively with such texts (and, of course, with the images contained in those texts) and gaining a perverse satisfaction from the depictions of suffering.

Certainly, Mary Wroth describes scenes of both male and female suffering with tremendous relish (a subject I touch on both in my monograph and in one of my blog entries. Rather than seeing her as colluding in the gratification of the male gaze, her frank enjoyment of scenes of suffering (not a few of which – Polarchos at the hands of the Princess of Rhodes, Selarinus humiliated before the Queen of Epirus – involve male victims of female tormentresses) suggests to me a lively female eroticism. Wroth’s vivid description of a jousting tournament – ‘the cruellest, and yet delightfullest Combate, (if in cruelty there can be delight) that Martiall men euer performed’ (The Countesse of Mountgomeries Urania, London, 1621, p. 62) – is a clear account of the erotics of the female gaze, and I am interested in exploring that gaze and its role in seventeenth-century sexual politics. All leads and suggestions welcome!

On Placebos

Probably of relevance to Daniel Goldberg’s comments on the history of pain (which I commented on in my last post) is Charles Rosenberg on ‘The Efficacy of Placebos: A Historian’s Perspective’ (Harvard, May 21). Goldberg has quite a lot to say about placebos, and their place in the history of the perception of pain, and Rosenberg will doubtless have plenty more to say on the subject. Too bad I’m thousands of miles away from Harvard! Perhaps there’ll be a transcript, or even a podcast…

On the Treatment of Pain

My attention was caught by two recent publications in the blog of The Appendix (‘a quarterly journal of experimental and narrative history’). The first is ‘Interpreting “Physick”: The Familiar and Foreign Eighteenth-Century Body’, by Lindsay Keiter. The second, in reply to the former, is Daniel S. Goldberg on ‘The History of Pain’.

Goldberg takes issue with Keiter’s assertion that ‘there was nothing available for mild, systemic pain relief in the eighteenth century’, frequently citing Esther Cohen, The Modulated Scream: Pain in Late Medieval Culture (University of Chicago Press, 2009) to show that pain management has a history going back much further than the eighteenth century. Samantha Sandassie weighs in on Goldberg’s side on Twitter, saying surgical casebooks & treatises contain a fair bit of information on pain management and noting early modern accounts such as those of Elizabeth Freke and Ralph Josselin.

This is, in a sense, a matter of nuance, rather than of absolutes; Sandassie herself shows pretty graphically in her own blog (Panacea: Musings on the History of Medicine) how the concept of pain in the medical context has changed over the centuries.

Goldberg goes on to discuss the issue of the effectiveness of pain management in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century contexts, arguing that modern conceptions of effectiveness and ‘what works’ cannot be applied to earlier periods. This approach emphasizes the perception of medical treatment and, again, the extent to which this is valid is a matter of degree. Benjamin Breen, editor of The Appendix, tweeted ‘on the other hand, the biological efficacy of drugs had a real historical role, no?

The main lessons I drew from the exchange were that Cohen’s work is probably worth a read and that the whole issue of premodern medical attitudes towards and treatment of pain is a complicated one. As far as I can see, Keiter didn’t get it fundamentally wrong; she merely overstated her case in an attempt to make a valid point.


Catching Up…

The last couple of months have been pretty hectic and I haven’t had much time to post here, so let me give a brief rundown of recent developments.

First, let me start with the stuff I’m missing out on, being here in Japan. I was sorry to miss a roundtable discussion on Violence, Victimhood and Virtue, Friday 2 May, 4:30-6:00 (with tea from 4 p.m.), Colin Matthews Room, Radcliffe Humanities Building, Woodstock Road, Oxford. The central question – ‘How do readers engage with a hero or heroine’s suffering, courage, pain, and defiance?’ – is right up my street, and I should have been very much in my milieu sipping tea in those august surroundings, listening to Eva Miller holding forth on ‘The Suffering Male and the Female Gaze in Modern Popular Culture’ and Kate Cooper on ‘Early Christian Martyr Narratives and the “Viral” Emotions’. But, alas, it was not to be!

I will also be unable to attend the conference on Early Modern Women, Religion and the Body (Loughborough, July 22-23), though at least I will be able to follow proceedings via Early Modern Women on Twitter. I’m especially interested in the following topic areas:

Suffering as part of religious experience and conversion
Spritual melancholy, madness, demonic possession, or witchcraft
Chastity and religious life
The miraculous or martyred female body

Yet another conference I missed out on was The Hurtful Body (Royal Flemish Academy, Brussels, November 21-22, 2013). This seems to have been a very fruitful meeting of minds and I was flattered (despite not being able to attend personally) to be invited to contribute a chapter to a collection of papers arising from the conference. The emphasis is on the visual arts, which lies beyond the province of my normal text-based research, and I am not sure whether I can come up with something that will satisfy the editors’ requirements, but I certainly intend to try!

Another little feather in my cap was an article in the latest volume of Recusant History (May 2014), which is out in print but doesn’t seem to available online yet. It’s on the general topic of ‘The Protestant Reception of Catholic Devotional Literature in England to 1700’, and isn’t related to attitudes towards suffering, but it’s from my research into Protestant readers of Catholic texts that I approached the whole subject of early modern suffering, so there’s a link there somewhere!

If that floats your boat, I’ve got another, related, paper coming out in the next issue of Reformation and Renaissance Review, entitled ‘Robert Persons’s Resolution and the Issue of Textual Piracy in Protestant Editions of Catholic Devotional Literature’. Again, it’s about the Protestant reception of Catholic literature rather than about issues relating to suffering, but it was through a study of Protestant readers of Catholic literature that my attention was drawn to the two radically different discourses of suffering developing synchronously during the seventeenth century.

I will be in Cambridge in September, for the Reformation Studies Colloquium and, between one thing and another, I’ll be in the UK for much of the summer. I will be in need of light relief, uplifting company, good food and beer, so like-minded individuals please take note & get in touch!

I’ll be back in due course with some more tidbits on suffering, but not for a while perhaps. Gird your gonads, grit your teeth and settle in for a bit of a wait!


Check out Jan Frans van Dijkhuisen’s review of Pain, Pleasure and Perversity here: You’ll need a JSTOR log-in to read the whole thing, but if anyone without one is particularly keen to read it, just e-mail me and I may be able to sort you out!

Anyway, here’s the first paragraph, just to give you a taster:

Pain, Pleasure and Perversity is a thoroughly researched and
highly original addition to the growing scholarly conversation on conceptions of suffering, embodiment, and sensory experience in early modern culture. Recent studies on these topics have focused at least in part on the impact that the religious upheavals of the Reformation period had on the way early modern Europeans understood the nature of embodiment and on the meanings they attached to bodily suffering. Yamamoto-Wilson’s study approaches the interplay between religious change and the cultural understanding of suffering more directly from the perspective of sexuality. His interest is partly in changing perceptions of self-inflicted religious suffering. He argues that during the seventeenth century self-inflicted pain, with self-flagellation as one of its more conspicuous manifestations, began to be seen as masochistic — as a species of sexual perversion, rather than as a form of imitatio Christi. Especially during the decades after the
Restoration, suffering seems to have lost much of the punitive and redemptive connotations that it carried in pre-Reformation culture. Pain, Pleasure and Perversity is divided into three parts that examine this development through the prisms of “the suffering self,” “the suffering of others,” and “suffering and gender.”

Van Dijkhuisen is the author of several works on the subject of early modern suffering, notably his recent monograph, Pain and Compassion in Early Modern English Literature and Culture.

Don’t say “Dark Ages”…

…not unless you want to upset medievalists!

I’m speaking from experience here. It’s not that I actually want to call them the Dark Ages, but I ventured to suggest in the LinkedIn Medieval and Renaissance Studies group that it was understandable that people used the term:

these were “Dark Ages” if you think it’s a good thing
not to have children growing up with gallows and whipping posts in the street, if you think that even if a surgery is done by the Top Surgeon it is still better with anaesthetics than without, if you don’t want to be told that your only real purpose here on earth is to partake of the sufferings of Christ.

I do temper that by saying:

However, they were not uniquely dark – oppressive attitudes towards suffering have prevailed, and still do prevail, in other ages and places – and if you believe that suffering may perhaps have a purpose and not simply be something to avoid then the medieval period was possibly even more enlightened than today.

But apparently the rider doesn’t make up for the original sin! I stirred up a bit of a hornets’ nest, it seems, and the discussion ended up in flames.

The same debate carried over into another thread, where feelings also ran pretty high, but without people actually going over the top.

Surgical Implements

A couple of weeks ago I posted in answer to a question on Quora about whether there was such a thing as necessary suffering. I began by saying that in an age before anaesthetics this question could hardly even have been asked. I then went on, in my wonted fashion, to discuss the issue in a rather abstract and philosophical way. This brings home the point rather more directly:


These surgical instruments from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries are (left) lithotomy dilator; dental forceps; trepan; dental forceps;
(right) double-bladed bistoury; forceps for extracting arrow head; bullet extractor;
(below) surgical saw.


Disturbingly erotic…or not?

I posted this a few months ago, but I’m having some trouble with spambots on a few of my posts, so I’m republishing with a slightly different permalink to see if that resolves the problem. Apologies to those who’ve already seen it!
An art historian is claiming that Dürer’s work is deeply erotic, in a highly explicit but subliminal way. The trouble is, she gives the answer away, and once you know the answer it’s impossible to unknow it! As a result, I can no longer look at the picture with objective eyes. So I’m asking you. Take a good look, spend several minutes and – here’s a hint – focus on other stuff going on in the picture, not on the woman breastfeeding the baby. It might also help if you half-close your eyes, forget that it’s representational art and think of it as something a bit like a Rorschach test. Think dirty!

Then take take a look at what Dr Garner says. Click on comments to see a summary of reactions so far…

overnight viagra australia viagra doser mp3   kamagraaustralia viagra valor   research paper how to write language resume   essay for the death penalty essay crash   essay topics f desertation com   dissertation service writingВ hh ru resume   where to buy viagra in stores viagra 30 coupon   generic levitra reviews niacin and viagra   is thesis a book essay comparing   parents help with math homework submit an essay   creative writing phd australia writing tutor   free proposal papers iseut resume   viagra soft tabs canada levitra jeune   psychology paper topics help with blog   interesting college admission essay topics h1n1 essays   troy essay send a resume   custom essay cheap dr seuss thesis   writing essay tips toefl ibt how to writing   creative narrative writingВ eh s resume   vermox buy cialis mexico   home essay example thesis on obama   essay writing terms wikipedia bio   exec cics assign essay business   best writing services reviews camelot essays   teenage pregnancy essay gaddafi thesis   buy viagra pfizer viagra di erbe   viagra and grapefruit lasix challenge   thesis topics electronics netcool resume   paid essay writing essay uniform   writing a proposal by the movies   resume multimedia wcdma thesis   how to write an intro paragraph for an essay grub no resume   how to know my ip address centos 7 passage essays   writing out numbers in essays qad resume   viagra h viagra m force   please do my assignment for me radio dj resume   definition essay on success umi theses   where can i buy cialis in calgary cialis pregnancy   oh no i forgot to write my essay resume tpop3 ru   cornell essay dbq 13 essay   dissertation essay writing resume aske   1stcanadianpharmacyy lasix horse   sample paper in apa format homework dabate   writing help online smu dessay schedule   custom research paper writers term paper wiki   research proposal samples resume criteria   how to write a melodrama xmas day essay   dissertation zitieren literaturverzeichnis resume pdf word   viagra online overnight rosacea viagra   cmp org homework help k12 homework   free viagra samples online cialis curativo   research paper annotated bibliography resume interest   professional creative writing editor services for university act essay tips   trusted pharmacy viagra online reviews viagra halal   movie ratings in theaters essays modern   awc pharmacy viagra stag do   how to find my public ip address windows 10 dawes act essay   psychology dissertation topics orphan essay   bought viagra fuerteventura viagra ceneo   thesis committee deutsch biblical essays   phd essay ghostwriting website ca arugment essays   benefits of writing essays first essays   how do i change my outlook email password on my iphone essays life pi   how to write in hylian alphabet write a speech   smallest amount viagra viagra flight   Г©chantillons gratuits viagra cialis works in   effects of viagra in women levitra 20 mm   research papers website lot book report   prednisone injection cialis en quito   writing editor dr dg hessayon   examples of an introduction for a research paper men essay   how do i delete an email account in my iphone acpi rtc resume   writing macros in excel perzi   thesis how to essey about me   memoirs essay examples of satire essay   same sex marriage essay topics ogun essay   buy viagra from safeway split a cialis   doing a research paper outline essay tow truck   cover research paper falstaff essay   viagra natural receita viagra mexico buy   creative writing aqa english photo essay pdf   research articles science wendy s resume   marcumar und viagra levitra ebay   pay to do psychology speech thesis 185   do my assignments do my assignments hp resume   buy assignments online 300 essay word   esl descriptive essay writer site uk autumn essay   cv writing service maidstone homework hex   assignment writing service australia buy top cv   prednisone doses viagra package   assign smarty da resume   dissertation binding service homework graphs   Buy Imigran Online Uk clay prednisone   liquid viagra mam cialis 2011 sales   singulair cena viagra geneirc   myself essay resume word pad   a descriptive essay about my room southern essays   school problems essay resume websites   how do i turn off email notifications on my iphone aphasia essay   viagra on the net viagra an alcohol   cialis 100 mg online no prescription prezzo cialis   write an essay on the topic my duty to my country mongol essays   viagra 100 mg yorum cgmp and viagra   sickle cell trait and viagra viagra font free   free online essay writer magnet essays   levitra informacion en espanol levitra 60 mg   how to write thesis structure ecm resume   academic writing services company a term paper   do my homework for menet assignability   thesis proposal writer for hire uk planning resume   proofreading vacancies online clincher essay   ganeric viagra cipro and valtrex   sql assignments trumpet essay   writing custom bios essay scan   cover letter for entry level help desk position resume pblv 59   essay tips resume for cvs   resume writing services duluth mn msa essay   how to write a self assessment paper sankranti essay   viagra for hard erection compra tu viagra   calis uk paypal viagra milligrams   professional blog ghostwriter website for university phd art thesis   brochure sample essay formal   anti death penalty essay antimony essays   cover letter for a retail store supervisor encarta essay   365 pills website viagra e eparina   viagra seek medical attention viagra btl   essay che guevara size 0 essay   thesis english homework binder   business plan writing services in houston write source   ciprofloxin buy viagra nepal   thesis_hook_after_header essay on utopia   thesis dissertation writing steve resume   resume writer orlando essay market   best school essay editing websites for university homework around   canadian pharmacy cialis 40mg off label cialis   leadership and management assignment link resume cv   research paper on parental involvement in education write a petiton   statistic project examples lie gpa resume   case stadyВ ai essay   buy a business plan comic essays   doxycycline hyclate 100 mg buy online viagra pablo   independence day essay in english mommybiz resume   financial crisis essay dessertations   thesis abstract about finance npr homework   hhh library homework help resume bsp cdma   example of essay written in apa format redirfs thesis   pay for my biology content sea essays   free essay edit windows 7 essay   how do u write a speech resume firms   viagra gegen cialis viagra btmg   l arginine viagra tomar viagra 19   resume for sql vendetta essay   help write an essay resume clothes   pharmacy vantelin knee   narrative essay write my thesis   dissertation topics in tourism and hospitality hands on essays   essay on exercise and obesity quote dvd essay   buy essay in 3 hours resume how   viagra free trial canada avodart nz   cilalis for cheap cialis en viagra   essay on child labor thesis builde   city transport essay c c unix resume   essay help introduction paragraph appic essay 4   indian meds for you cialis mutuelle   professional analysis essay ghostwriting website us thesis+ppt   buy nexium without a rx cialis 5 mg 28   us based essay writing service kurzweil essay   how to write a letter to self in the future resume images   how to write a self assessment letter le dissertation   thesis proposal letter humurous essay   books to help with essay writing 6 word essay   viagra cincinnati viagra kaufen usa   social problems a case study approach general essays   buytablets viagra zovirax vs   semiotics essay aviation essay   thesis ideas economics completion of   how to end a compare and contrast essay ohmae thesis   internet essay writing tempest essays   buy flagyl 1000 mg levitra imagem   energy drink research papers myanmar essay   viagra banned commercial viagra ice   thesis statement examples deforestation camping essays   how do i convince myself to write my paper thurber essay   help writing a thesis statement for research paper free writers   hematology case study help failing essay   viagra pГҐ nett i sverige pom juice viagra   viagra free sample uk cialis bone pain   how to make a research paper homework edu   how to write an essay about my school in french rockette resume   buy viagra online web meds cialis mit 23   sample resume for non profit component essay   current controversial issues research paper resume helps   thesis paper on bioinformatics suv essay   tagalog thesis topics list pdf homework   research report 1l resume tips   thesis in complex analysis essay on living   analysis examples essay spa job resume   great eskimo vocabulary hoax and other irreverent essays lathi homework   buy custom essay papers adhd essay   case university new york cover page mla   best resume writing service perth case study 5   thesis ideas information technology thesis topc   Cialas gel 36 hr buy nexium online   where to get viagra in kolkata golden viagra ed   nexium 80 mg viagra fas mal   how to write a essayВ resume girl   either or logical fallacy essay leads resume pmp   sample cover letter banking internship proofing text   viagra average dose precios levitra   essays competition good bad rest paper   essay contract service ronald resume   literature review poster template homework aids   how to write a college admissions essay admitance essay   property management dissertation topics book critiques   creative writing bcot essay roosevelt   thesis statement for analytical essay vlan assignment   popular personal statement writers for hire for university thesis french   cialis online mastecard viagra on line   writing tutorial service carleton coursework mark   cialis usage viagra kalp   viagra remix piripituchi viagra minoxidil   multivariate statistics r homework a resume letter   brief introduction about yourself for interview sat the essay   how to write my college application essay want wife essay   cialis modo do uso viagra zug   my master thesis project thesis gutter   how to write a admission essay resume iis   hairdressing resume sample sample lab   esperienze con cialis viagra history of   essays on problems in the community essay wrting   how can i write a document on my ipad well papper   concept papers topics p e essays   make up of cialis levitra at boots   how i write my name in chinese flobert thesis   losartan viagra side effects levitra how long   pre done resume essay nursing   old writing paper chastity essays   viagra nobel prize viagra oster   professional resume writing services jacksonville fl age on resume   minister viagra speed up viagra   thesis for high school dropouts hiding homework   acknowledgments thesis arts resume   cheap essay writing service canada hybrid resume   college essay cover page thesis rybka   cialis cheapest lowest price usa diflucan images   dissertation components bcg resume tips   buying a descriptive essay for college resume this   essay egypt will writing uk   buy viagra nsw trimix vs viagra   kann man viagra gewг¶hnen poppers   soil and water conservation essay examples type a essay   thesis paper wind energy essays on voip   essay online service enotes essay   thesis about speech communication radio resume   phd thesis writing service resume walmart   fafipa vestibular prozac com viagra   please email your resume to smeal essays   achat viagra en ligne quebec bulgarian viagra   do actors and professional athletes get paid too much essay resume surveyor   where can i get my cv done nietchze essays   cv for phd application harvard winning thesis   dissertation proposal format resume plugin   thesis narrative cbt essays   alabama online homework helper research resume   cialis to order in canada get viagra canada   buy college term paper steroid thesis   how to set up mail on my new iphone 8 thesis proquest   essay on trade can help the poor essay reasoning   college application letter spinal thesis   sample case study research book lists   essay outline template i write a song   help write a thesis statement essay man popes   prednisone children viagra for copd   cialis prescription drugs klonopin cialis   girl viagra viagra cost 2013   lsu creative writing faculty resume mensa   their eyes were wactching god essay art phd thesis   promotion business case example thesis bridges   essay video games need a paper   writing the college essay sas stat resume   best online writing essay onworld   essay writers australia resume in job   cheap analysis essay ghostwriting services us artisis resume   essays for university application two essay   buy original cialis online viagra em bh   resume de l acte 4 scene 7 de l avare mla essay setup   personal essay help resume bcg   college persuasive essay outline template assign rights   cheap drug generic generic viagra red viagra konya   why write college admissions essays aeneas essay   where do you purchase viagra levitra canada   nordic pulp and paper research journal abbreviation resume biology   where can i buy an essay maus ii essay   how do i write an essay on my macbook air samurai thesis   best place to buy viagra online yahoo answers drugs lasix   computer on essay geology resume   thesis outline latex embedded thesis   custom essay writing for hire for college gender thesis   journalism essay topics encarta essay   harvick kevin viagra fluoxetine qtc   tonic wine viagra slow down viagra   cialis ibuprofen wechselwirkung viagra benicar   a good thesis statement for the rocking horse winner starter resume   my dream job essay example thesis netflix   lowest prices on viagra viagra board   goals essay resume build up   film thesis questions unisa thesis   buy cheap online prescription viagra cialis with water   how to write a good application essay ph d thesis   viagra online video levitra mhd   write a thesis statement for me thesis csr pdf   custom essays paper fauvism essay   cytotec pastillas cialis cmi   family celebrations essay book agents   inspiration essay topic write a circle   viagra tablet price forum su levitra   a website that helps you with your homework sap pa resume   generic cialis soft tab levitra diarrhea   best executive chef resume crack up essays   kinder writing paper jamaica essay   sample cover letter for sales account manager my mentor essay   custom dissertation writing service online mq resume   resume writer bangalore efficient essay   viagra medicine on sale online c5 pill cialis   embedded systems cover letter sample essay on utopia   wuthering heights essay topics essays dreams 2   ks3 problem solvingВ 6 sigma resume   how to write a good 5 paragraph essay homework poems   paxil and viagra china cialis   thesis defense committee silly essay   viagra kills kgr 100 viagra   how to delete flagged emails from iphone cotr resume   mail order viagra viagra use dogs   servant leadership thesis find writing   essay growing up type essay   ut quest homework services resume sap xi   sprite viagra viagra psoriasis   food technology gcse coursework examples completing your   thesis examples for compare and contrast essay students resume   Generic Elavil viagra gay test   essay about it resume vs cv   Generic Levitra Professional ventolin dosing   buying cheap free sale viagra viagra antabuse nausea   greencanadacare samples levitra   cialis daily dose pharmacy farmacia viagra   hortatory exposition thesis argument recommendation chris lu resume   help research paper format building essays   what is gender academic papers resume servises   description essay of acts essay   examples of a thesis statement for an essay essay 300 words   phoenix liquid cialis viagra in europe   review my paper free procces paper   excel viagra viagra sweden   medications without perscriptions.... buy doxycycline 2   creative writing versus technical writing essays author   can you buy cialis at walmart nolvadex nedir   write my bibliography army 42a resume   bodybuilding viagra dosage propecia mdl 2331   article analysis essay question essay   essay mla citation ny essay   apply texas essay c help kes essay   how to write an amazing college essay usaid essay   my favorite teacher essay peeve essays   temps de conservation du viagra spray on viagra   help writing a descriptive essay scandal essay   research proposal topic my bibliography   marketing essay writing f100 essay   dissertation binding services liverpool sexual essays   buy ready essays english help   effets secondaires cialis viagra legit viagra   othello thesis a resume   report writing pay essay genretrk   eroxim usa testing viagra   homework help worksheets the help writer   writing resume change careers 1 page resume   thesis advisor definition mask essay   writing a thesis outline online speech   safe doses of cialis viagra research   buying a paper for cheap essay of study   psychology paper example risky essay   linconcin con eucalipto viagra 26 anni   format of writing research paper my essay net   research paper about women in islam age dark essay   viagra other medical uses viagra x plus   how to write a good essay about leadership resume cobol   do my chemistry homework for me build your cv   stress in the workplace essay red kayak essay   why chicago essay essay first job   qut thesis template numbered sport thesis   film homework thesis problems   many essay my dissertation   homework vs no homework ilych essays   lavitra melatonin nz   conclusion saturn essay resume personal   pay for my creative essay online writing papers   best american essays online tree essays   creative writing snowman great essays   viagra gold review viagra power v8   research methods in creative writing kroll essay thematic   someone who made an impact in your life essay ut austin essay   do my assignments for me ppm software   essay job sample recent movies   viagra non prescription slogan de viagra   how to write a college essay in one night how 2 do resume   tosh 2.0 viagra viagra black ant   prince of self pity hamlet critical essay original resume   thesis statement for a descriptive essay homework net   custom reflective essay writer websites prank resume   corporate finance homework help hegel essay   professional paper writing service pmp mba resume   hmong homework help line cv writing free   essay woman rights resume essay   how long do college application essays have to be essay trade   proventil for sale viagra gpo   top essays editor site us mcgill resume   thesis defence rsm 8466 gessay   computer problem solvingВ event essay   neurontin online no prescription viagra e fans   cialis online genuine valtrex   help with college level research paper kelloggs essays   tretinoin 20 20 gm from india lasix eye centre   admissions essay editing service fnn coursework   get maximum benefit viagra viagra no rj   write essay about my school is not doing enough new job resume   writing an observation paper essay order uk   professional dissertation writers opion essays   picture of viagra viagra bangalore   papers examples essays on voip   essay on modern life assign macro   cialis pills tadalafil under tongue dissolve cialis ou viagra   free short essays for students phd theis   turner thesis econs essay   reading assignments for 6th graders rhetoric essays   law essays free essay mapping   determining paper weight per m ap lang essay   essays in persuasion lantana essays   eriacta vs viagra buy online viagra dall'india   write best man speech usc essays mba   cialis over seas diflucan ibs   order of parts of a research paper essay upsr 2017   literature synthesis fanny resume   how to write big numbers thesis playlist   christianity homework help of book reports   heart of darkness essay brides speech   coronary heart disease case study chagoya thesis   mla format cover page homeless essay   can you take viagra through airport viagra approved   risques prise viagra valtrex in aids   how to write novel sims 3 tips essay   case study assignment help diplomat resume   how do i open a zip file on my ipad email crossfit essays   pay to do college homework rest   psu creative writing major titanic essay   cheap essay buy m thesis   case study examples for psychology resume heating   cialis for sale payment paypal node/178   ms thesis proposal format effects essay   thesis about elementary education aboration essay   where to buy viagra in london make viagra shot   where is the thesis statement typically found in an essay f100 essay   how to transfer pdf to my ipad assign meaning   thesis statement handout high school racers resume   my dream house descriptive essay felbers thesis   viagra pill non prescription viagra blue lips   where can i buy qsymia in canada viagra horses   donna young writing paper can do homework   viagra in shoppers drug mart www viagra kaufen   thesis grad school essay order uk   greek mythology research paper emersons essays   essay on attitude autoessay   best college essay ghostwriter for hire usa essay upsr 2019   single mother essay essay bullying   political thesis essayheleper   how to write your thesis in your resume i search essays   buy a research paper online term papers lab   healthy man pharmacy amoxil indication   Cheapest Viagra Anywhere herbal viagra buy   buy ivey mba essays   canadian superdrug store viagra ajanta pharma   performance enhancing viagra the drug viagra   research paper questions write assay   relocation nursing cover letter resume formates   sales consultant experience resume 25u mos resume   college writing essay format goor resume   how to write an essay about yourself mla page format   essay on electrical safety essay cat pet   essays written in french cms thesis cern   business plan it consulting template rotten tomato   problems with viagra viagra 4 tablets   us pharmacy cytotec online viagra   wann kann man viagra nehmen viagra uah   gatech resume help essay cafeteria   buy custom written essays get my homework   best mba cv examples research essays   viagra dosage for erectile dysfunction clomid club   purdue the owl i and me essays   depaul creative writing program disorders essay   essay writer online ode essay   cheap viagra with other than visa card viagra pill ring   do my paper me bressay primary   professional resume writing service buffalo ny essay on mobile   personal statement english creative writing buy logic essay   order paper aiu resume   mail order medicine from mexico viagra at nudist   order lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide without prescription ghb y viagra   how to write a psychology hypothesis jobs on resume   ap central english language and composition synthesis essay sexuality essay   cheap viagra super force cosa e il viagra   feminism in medea essays firo-b essay   administrative order of assignment resume t one   tvo homework help childhood essay   what drug class is viagra make own viagra   good thesis proposal example resume for scm   pay to do biology blog post editing a essay   can i write essays on an ipad thesis dict cc   depakote viagra interaction viagra dirty   photosynthesis car engine mlitary essays   imaginative essays resume no jobs   where can i buy periactin pills usa viagra sales   oberlin creative writing undergraduate lampman essay   best custom writing website house of essays   how do i open my icloud email on my ipad norton essays   ts eliot essay on hamlet my health essay   how to delete mail on iphone 6s monomyth essays   viagra trial offer viagra in cozumel   creative writing inspirational quotes avid essay   generic link user viagra yo new movie viagra   how to send picture to email from iphone 6 50 essay great   thesis writing methodology sample about cases   globalization and the media essays resume futures   remind me to do my homework when i get home oppinion essays   how to delete all facebook messages on iphone 7 law assignments   efeitos do viagra no organismo feminino viagra e zoloft   dissertation humor ecpe essays   online pharmacey viagra una mujer viagra   resume writing services in atlanta ga wine term paper   essay work critica essay   assignment 201 working in the hair industry help mcaa school   buy research papers no plagiarism cheap my garden essay   nursing scholarship essay samples essay+bierce   four paragraph essay write for money   thesis checker online sympathy essay   sample customer service resume cover letters faddis resume   thomas jefferson speeches and writings resume itil   how to remove a mail account from iphone ios 11 mfa or m.f.a.   thinkinh it321 homework   Order cheap cialis cialis strengths   spray female ejaculation motilium english   clomid days 3-7 versus 5-9   tufts career services resume waltari thesis   career aspirations essay sample assignment c   thesis about education write a thesus   write an essay on grandparents men essays   dissertation index wwi essay   critical thinking medicine thesis embargo   walmart training and development essays de billes essay   what does research paper mean richwine thesis   an entrepreneur you admire essay thesis rabies   tester viagra gratuitement cialis y hbp   nexium package insert accutane videos   dissertation bac francais 2009 essay book help   when to write out numbers in an essay mla a case study   difference between thesis dissertation and research a movers resume   college research paper topics argumentative perl resume sas   oil price drop essay write esay   writing essays for scholarships bss resume   nifedipine sublingual, 10 mg viagra 50 gr   how to write a journal article cruelty essays   buy paper lanterns uk rice romp essay   viagra norvasc drug interaction diflucan safety   business ethics thesis statement kica essay   library paper essay word   efectos de viagra en jovenes viagra mit paypal   professional dissertation writer site for college resume on mac   why college is important essays cmsgt resume   viagra super online canada pharmacy diflucan kapszula   emma jane austen essay gibbs resume   viagra nascar jacket free valtrex   cialis extra strength age of viagra use   примеры narrative essay iseut resume   wanted to buy zithromax from discrete co whats viagra for   essays on writing flickr essay   overnight pharm viagra cong dung viagra   medco coverage cialis 3 dollar viagra   tom tokio hotel overdosis viagra problemas cialis   viagra uk dr fox viagra kalender   college essay writing prompts good case study   should you take viagra on an empty stomach cialis perth wa   essay on winter vacation for class 3 don resume   essay entry order law blog   viagra how long viagra viva   write my essay tumblr edu book report   thesis on bathroom design resume by mail   does homework help students thesis usf   viagra tablets in uk rx s viagra   how to use l arginine as viagra viagra spiked   is it safe to buy viagra in mexico viagra uit india   do assignments online resume rsum   top dissertation conclusion ghostwriters for hire for school fs cd resume   brand name viagra in usa buy viagra berlin   buy viagra at boots nightclub viagra   How to Make Watermelon Viagra cipro and milk   cialis nasonex viagra de 50   master thesis example latex essay t   which countries can you buy cialis anu ang viagra   purchase doxycyline hydrate for dogs proventil spray   phd by thesis only a termpaper   management resume retail retek monsanto resume   black market cialis viagra no doctor   canadian pharmacies online viagra chat   cialis generika kaufen forum cialis apteka   edexcel designed gcse history coursework assignments mos resume   viagra generico pagamento paypal levitra flomax   order viagra viagra silagra 100 price   meglio cialis o viagra cobra 120 viagra   homework help pay finish thesis   police resume cover letter resume charts   writing a successful college application essay essay habits   essay write louis xvi essay   my first car essay resume icon   essay writing sites tipler homework   standard resume form homework cells   writing assignement gotovie resume   best place to buy essay paper resume saver   viagra increases nitric oxide buy viagra reddit   hong kong mfa creative writing mba essay ru   essays persuasive topics bfa thesis blog   professional essay writers review essays examine   ordinare viagra per telefono proscar merck   common font size for academic papers guide to thesis   how to write great essaysВ thesis hook map   discount doxycycline no prescription cialis pastile   argumentative essay on abortion pro life ilm course work   formal research paper outline a-g list   need buy essay children essays   buy a research paper for cheap essay busy life   where to get viagra samples lasix webmd   how to write a good college admissions essay what an essay   thesis template uq java c resume   viagra price melbourne lasix eye centers   metformin available on the internet 5mg cialis   reviews for essay writing services new movie   order finpecia zma and viagra   proofreading an essay cc essays   on line pharm cialis au maroc   essay about finance career seedfolks essay   viagra dosge cialis xarelto   marijuana legalization paper essay on title   ghost writing service c ftp resume   best results for taking cialis viagra refill   cheap bibliography editor website for masters download report   professional application letter editor websites us p i p resume   writing prompts tumblr anti hero essay   russia status of viagra nolvadex cialis   professional annotated bibliography editor services for mba hamelt essays   custom essay service homework helo   graduate school thesis proposal bochtanas essay   how to write a tell me about yourself essay militay resume   viagra too expensive moroccan viagra   pay for college essay essay flex   creative writing resources for teachers mallarme essay   aalto university master thesis template what is a case   persuasive essay powerpoint england essay   thesis introduction past tense analis essay   viagra souffle au coeur aspirin vs viagra   how do i stop spam mail on my iphone essays racism   what is business plans dj essay   cv writing reviews essay generator   best site to buy viagra uk cause of viagra   research paper writing service essay viewpoint   viagra bad side effects propecia e cialis   the thesis ambassador on assignment   how to delete mail from iphone xs essay for nyu   marketing study cases ending thesis   superior writing services litary essay   factory farm thesis statement master thesises   thesis on database pdf servers resume   namibia university red pill viagra   viagra in the water christine lavin clomid iui   online pharmacy with echeck for viagara viagra woman   middle class essay hume essays pdf   short essay style ecatt resume   can someone do my assignment nmci resume   buy essay paper online uwo resume   risque viagra pГ©rimГ© cytotec safety   sociology paper example excel ms resume   viagra online oversea indian cialis   buy cheap essay online brief essay   how to write an essay on your family qa faa resume   christmas wrapping paper suppliers origami essay   definition of narrative essay love god essays   how to write a 4 paragraph essay essays greed   essay editing jobs philippines moral thesis   college essay for transfer students ccdc2 resume   how do i change caller id on my ipad homework away   blue generic pill viagra viagra for babies   es viagra o vimax costof viagra   world war 1 essay bird essay   diovan shipped overnight for next day clomid round 1   generic viagra uk europe cialis en chile   geometry homework help resume may   the best writing service mla essay rules   essay about racism forum essay   buy viagra sample levitra brasil   generic female viagra review is viagra an otc   dissertation binding shops london resume thread   ielts table essay essay dreams   buy doxycycline hyclate 100mg cipro effects   help me on writting research paper essay for uconn   example of writing outline cover letter eg   dissertation youtube essay hamburger   how to write a good academic essay cancer essay   how to write career objective essay swot resume   computer revolution essay flatcv resume   statement of the problem in thesis a paper for me   walmart pharmacy viagra viagra zagreb   academic writing service essay tech   resume sales experience examples s tate thesis   negotiation analysis paper machuca essays   herbal viagra pills viagrasuperative   writing a expository essay in essays   take viagra after meal avodart jel   bacteria essay sap paom resume   research paper writing process myassignmentnet   how to change my email address on my iphone 4s statement paper   essay outline example ap cover letter   how to know my ip address in phone resume device   essay writing service essay writers essay script   subscribe viagra motilium syrup   does viagra professional work gel come viagra   what is the thesis for the story of an hour resume titile   senate bill about viagra commercials buy viagra ebay   viagra soft tabs directions viagra how to get   hook and thesis cimic thesis   how to write an essay uk biography on   cause/effect essay topics formula 1 essay   buy cytotec en mexico to usa generic cialis   write an essay for me mudd thesis   animal human surgery sample essay authors books   affordable online mfa creative writing jingle writer   dissertation ideas for computer science thesis tiac   blood plasma essay essays in film   viagra liverpool clomid multiple   custom writing essays services done homework   boserup thesis essay on space   hi i have essay about friendship help 100ree essays   essay outline example resume linguist   how to start a narrative essay about yourself nursing essay   crestor without prescription apotheke levitra   thesis format phd tok essay title   cheapest essays for sale essayer de voir   defending a thesis casher resume   paper looking poincare essays   essay writing step by step papers examples   best rated essay writing service the book report   viagra o similar para mujeres cialis cost in us   walmart alli 60 mg i took a viagra   acheter viagra pfizer pas cher need viagra 30   phd thesis help india thesis plc   mfa creative writing programs southern california bank thesis   movie reviews ebert ironweed essay   economics thesis topics undergraduate epicurus essay   efectos viagra para jovenes viagra pesni   where can i buy viagra in nyc cialis and weight   how to know my ip address in linux do my homeowrk   how to delete email account off iphone 7 do my home work   posso comprar viagra na farmacia sem receita sloka lasix   written case study analysis doctors essay   radio dj job description resume lead thesis   persuasive research paper topics college students resume exam   procrastination essay examples mfa courses   advantages online learning essay best essay web   buy essay papers uwa sese thesis   purchase viagra from india gofeminin viagra   viagra and testosterone levitra germany   curriculum vitae online maker samp le resume   viagra and oysters 200 mg of viagra   essay services us cover letter   business letter writing service help in resume   writing an english essay bio comm   buspar online without prescription viagra xanax   concluding essay phrases essay on novels   popular argumentative essay writer website usa my thesis title   introduction of a research project movie essay   sociology dissertationsВ finding essay   early childhood philosophy paper resume columns   writing essay for graduate school admission post job resume   last holidays essay resume etl   venta de viagra + argentina buenos aires free viagra jokes   professional dissertation results writers websites for masters print resume   what are the parts of a case study vim resume   order metformin online awesome viagra   essay service writing dessay reviews   rapid tab viagra lotrel viagra   critical essay thesis ip mpls resume   term paper library management system send resume   how to create new mail folder on iphone 8 meiosis essay   viagra para mujer en costa rica lasix renogram   kan ik viagra kopen bij de apotheek viagra billiger   lerk jet ebay viagra pills   top online resume writing services pastors resume   viagra and metoprolol cialis in london   professor resume sampel praxis 1 essay   approved pharmacyrx medical jual viagra kl   custom movie review proofreading service au ladybug essay   boston college application essay topics margins resume   order a paper essay masters svhs homework   essay in teaching essay colors   ez online pharmacy buy viagra usa lasix hives   essays on moby dick essay on rabies   viagra generico en farmacias espaГolas cialis warnings   essay words audit it resume   online pharmacy uk viagra cialis reactions   cytotec over the counter kamagra 100mg   issue papers format uga essays   best essay ever written oedipus admission help   research paper english topics resume graphics   marketing dissertation proposal essays on india   college essay writing service us army essays   help my assignment alaska homework   favorite food essay view msc thesis   essay motivation teach writing   really interesting research paper topics content topic   why i want to be a nurse essay tamogami essay   cialis by mail with prescription viagra high blood   cialis online sicuro levitra laima   phgh rx ketamine viagra   credo homework help columbus essay   buy orlistat 60 mg with no prescription viagra indicatii   write an essay on your mother thesis stola   thesis intro outline scp resume port   online pharmacies for viagra viagra afghanies   cialis vs levitra cost viagra uk review   red viagra cialis xarelto zithromax   creative writing groups washington dc essay just war   clomid online us pharmacy whats viagra for   essays on paper thesis faulkner   ebay viagra use viagra video   viagra 50mg or 100mg viagra 69   ranbaxy viagra pastila viagra   pay to get nursing cv resume terbaru   free argument essay com net resume   buy cover letter medea thesis   medical residency personal statement writing services awa gre essays   viagra soft tabs cialis on nhs   writing a commencement speech arnold essays   top report ghostwriting sites for mba usc essays 2012   how to write an college application essay resume 44 ru   pfizer viagra south africa viagra dreampharm   cheap mba persuasive essay example colleage essay   is viagra safe to use cytotec d&c   professional annotated bibliography writing sites online service writing   essay paragraph capsim homework   nursing assignment topics pet care resume   where to buy viagra uk boots viagra libre   antidepressant female viagra cvs viagra price   buy malegra pro 100 viagra usa rezept   dream essay writing personal resume   write an essay on country essay diagrams   viagra emoticon viagra display   business plan writers manchester legit essay   how do i delete an old email address from my iphone tense resume   essay on biodiversity write a prayer   how many mg is a single dose of azithromycin for chlamydia viagra slogan   sex and cialis viagra vaistai   writing music on ipad pro us thesis   write an essay on the market place near my house how start essay   buy cipro online canada viagra deneyimi   dut thesis repository frees essays   cialis 100 viagra alkolle   cv for phd in computer science essays quotes   legitimate essay writing sites layour essay   write essay on my first day in school nacirema essays   example thesis paragraph for a research paper corseworks   study of case essay john mill   global marketing assignment buy best thesis   viagra online free shipping australia viagra in qatar   how to write references in researchВ ccna 2 homework   how can i send an email on my ipad essy writting   thesis statement in descriptive essay essays in hindi   writing an application essay dessay torrents   can i write a letter on my apple ipad antigone essays   viagra administration biancone lasix   writing faculty bernal thesis   research paper video top phd cv help   mba essay ghostwriter mba on a resume   gcse chemistry coursework rates of reaction method type homework   ou commander du viagra en ligne cialis quotes   buy viagra online with prescription viagra handshake   how i write my cover letter pinches thesis   how to write a strategy paper sale papers   law essay help writen essays   rate generic viagra cialis lotrel   thesis binding griffith university online writer   how to type a book title in an essay reviews   essay single sex education modren essays   cialis japan cialis quel dose   can i pay someone to do my assignment write a source   creative writing on rainfall it dissertation   what is the best essay services horrible essay   professional resume writing service gold coast carlyles essay   paper writing services reviews copys of resume   cost of generic viagra propecia dry eye   how to write the perfect college essay homework letter   persuasive essay topics tok essays   buy paper wristbands in store essay muet 2012   essay writers for pay essay bible job   homework help quebec english thesis   dissertation doctor da vinci essay   cipro without prescription jual viagra usa   women cialis viagra kokteyl   is much ado about nothing a comedy essay congo essay   introduction quality assurance essay book feedback   essay editing service canada homework at ua   uab graduate school thesis format bpo qa resume   pfizer viagra patent mua ban viagra   inductive qualitative research homework helo   college paper writing services reviews article topics   what is a college thesis essay contrast   steps to writing a paper uniqu resume   essay writing words epik essay   standardized testing essay any job resume   master dissertations buy esl resume   do my dissertation write a barcode   thesis order supreme essays   grapefruit juice with viagra viagra sperms   gifts essay tada thesis   life cycle assessment thesis asthma essay   research paper to buy resume tech   que es mas caro viagra o cialis viagra class c   tsh low on synthroid prednisolone drug   cialis macular degeneration levitra mexico   personal essay editor service thesis of 1984   viagra dosage result kids and viagra   writing paper help homework math   introduction sentences for essays resume plc   best american essay writers essay with mla   how many body paragraphs should a research paper have? thesis fomat   research papers essays term paper jute   cover letter writing service brisbane essay on night   resume writing for hire usa angelou essay   research essay help anne essaye   thesis college application essay identity essay   essay writting service phd proposal   cialis professional viagra proof   expository essay ideas help with essay   research thesis writing ss thesis   essay teenage problems sbio online   what to write college essay about morrie essay   orange county resume writing service resume new grad   how does viagra help erection movie on viagra   buy viagra online paypal viagra lungs   college paper writing help obama hecklers   powerpoint 2007 templates thesis help uk   samples of scientific reports pp presentation   business plan help for veterans sara thesis   scientific essay resume dates   viagra vs arginine nanox9 viagra   how do i delete voicemail messages on my iphone hrm assignment   viagra suppositories side effects viagra nel vino   cialis generic cheapest price free shipping levitra tl   literature review services homework files   philosophy assignments lied on resume   hamlet is not insane essay sample of paper   viagra in shops uk metformin sigma   non prescription synthroid motilium warning   english as a universal medium of communication essay resume 360 kit   how to write session description origin essays   best business plans flawless resume   camagra oraljelly@net hr avodart ndc   best resume writing service 2013 superman essays   viagra spc uk viagra 24 uur   order cialis online us pharmacy cytotec buy uk   cover letter for recruitment consultant essay pappers   bachelor thesis conclusion example myth essay   viagra online from india viagra classe a   can you take viagra alpha blockers cialis dose   persuasive essay for bullying attorney resume   closed to viagra amoxil veterinary   buy essays online townie mi resume   language personal statement moonfleet essay   thesis on social media and education uptodate resume   i would like to buy generic cialis clomid twins rate   how to write issue essay in gre nursing resume   custom bibliography proofreading sites online homework 215   homework help pre algebra publicity essay   viagra allergy 10 mg di cialis   kpmg case studyВ hot to essays   holt online essay grading essay on tawhid   how to solve math word problems a case study on   everyday cialis online pharmacy patent for cialis   powerpoint presentation help essays by ibsen   como hago un viagra casero propecia xpecia   buy blue diamond viagra viagra gumtree   thesis logistics pdf how to papers   essay cultural differences guiliani resume   research paper examples apa someone resume   online book report service online book report service metallica essay   best moments in life essay essay appraisal   viagra professional canadian pharmacy viagra britain   essay modern technology cheap custom   resume content layout bank thesis   cialis daily from united states kamagra et viagra   sample business reports beowulf thesis   mil maneras de morir viagra levitra gel   define thesis in english clarity resume   tudor homework help games galileo essay   research essay proposal ratings movies   write my thesis tuition help   autumn writing paper paulson resume   bibliography apa free analysis paper   walmart pharmacy viagra viagra lupus   write my paper login write cheap cv   local thesis abstract review cae   when to use cialis daily viagra patent nz   ratings of films edu 5   great gatsby essay testing probe   constitutional law essay resume eu   new resume styles samples capital essay   get help with statistics homework usc essay help   hiding keywords in a resume topics thesis   buy cialis online fast shipping clomid klomen   crime and punishment essay on poverty movie critics   how are naics codes assigned nyu cpr essay   technical writing research letter writing   crucible essay resume retired   thesis antioxidant activity plants homework from   dissertation abstracts international a movie review   essay tv speech english paper   it dissertation ideas do my hw for me   write an essay on your classroom pearl essay   rooster video resume coherent thesis   argumentative research paper ideas knitting resume   how to delete email account off iphone x csr p c resume   unisa journalism creative writing panduan resume   prednisone back pain picture viagra   harvard finance thesis essay format in   microsoft yahoo merger thesis magwitch essay   best best essay ghostwriting for hire for phd cival war essay   persuasive essay guidelines biography is   professional research paper ghostwriters services online roman essay   viagra 2 day delivery leki levitra   write my paper write my research paper thesis ru   viagra knee pain viagra in uk   essay rush service boulder essay   example expository essays essays on oprah   fluoxetine and xls medical zoloft sleep   presidential scholarship essay resume marina   us viagra overnight online viagra   how to write an conclusion paragraph for an essay csr essay pdf   essays topics list normandy essay   sample resume objectives mechanical engineering ocr course work   writing proposal dissertation essay 7 sat   critical analysis essay example book it review   viagra overnight no prescription viagra sample   writing format soliloquy essay   thesis statement generator for narrative essay essays of enid   research paper author order tv and homework   essay on helping others http put resume   renewable energy essay sap tpm resume   how to write a newsletter article free essay law   common essay prompts resume pages   viagra korea cialis daily 5 mg   media networking essay cfi resume   essay on development of sports in india essay quesions   friends with benefits essay usaid resume   viagra canada viagra 4 horas   bystolic supply shortage cheap soft cialis   paraphrasing and summarising homework stamp   thesis typing jobs marriage thesis   massage therapy business plan powerpoint type my content   viagra vs viagra jet daily mail viagra   article writing site cartel essay   crestor rosuvastatina tabletas cialis airport   canada viagra el viagra cubano   master thesis in computer science textile essay   blank writing paper with picture box flas essay   how to write essay describing yourself ibm dpe resume   guide to essay writing university write a resume   mst creative writing oxford interview esl writing   cheapest resume writing service bra essay   best ways to write college essays ready resume   effective speech writing write a pamplet   viagra money laundering viagra in europa   safest place buy viagra online top viagra store   cortisone prednisone buy soft cialis   le viagra sans ordonnance viagra dependence   buying term papers review moskau resume   honey viagra viagra price rm   finance homework help reddit and coursework   how to write a research proposal sample royden homework   custom research proposal ghostwriters site for university regiment dessay   examples of bad college admissions essays homework car   thesis statement for persuasive essay resume seeding   professional essay writing companies essay mill   master thesis english example drag report   viagra super dulox force viagra x lei   essay paper writing service homework porn   free sample viagra stent e viagra   essay writing reviews ashridge essay   best online proofreader pmsm thesis   learning how to write essays tattoo resume   female viagra canada viagra catena   can you buy viagra in tijuana kamagra zsel   literature based dissertation malvolio essay   ems term paper resume du coran   buy pink viagra for women viagra defense   how to critique creative writingВ essay phpid   self concept literature review essay park kids   how can i print an email from my ipad mini resume exmaples   viagra song propranolol tired   teradata datastage resume life essay net   professional creative writing writer for hire for mba nyu cpr essay   unc honors thesis guidelines thesis ebooks   audience analysis paper sex homework   how to delete email account on iphone 6 ios 11 ipcc resume   business gcse coursework help nelson homework   attention grabbing introductions for essays essay edit free   buy zyvox no prescription viagra pets   apa citation format for online journal article my memoir essay   upload your essay tey essay   critical analysis essay on lincoln but because   sildenafil versus kamagra viagra in nz   professional persuasive essay writing site dba resume sql   professional writing services houston critical mind   top critical essay writing for hire for college resume handbook   cv writing service bolton mcsd resume   how can i receive emails on my iphone 6 homework pay""   viagra with doctor precription digoxin viagra   example of research paper introduction apa the movie book   how to write a good personal statement on cv esl phd cv help   database research paper thesis good   resume badan usaha creative essay   how long will it take to write my paper causual essay   can i track my stolen ipad with serial number write a article   thesis and dissertation library a103 essay   ringtone viva viagra brand levitra   college essay for transfer students egyptian essay   writing a position essay resume samp   feminism essay essay bank uk   writing essay example resume minor in   psychology coursework help resume drop   where to buy christmas wrapping paper fanny resume   how to do your homework with adhd camera essay   go on writing penis essay   respect essay for kids resume memo   essay direct city resume   buy paper origami cranes essay hope   ielts writing task 1 band 9 answer sectonal thesis   seeing blue while viagra do viagras work   buy tidamax real cheap nom de viagra   master dissertation thesis in vn ua   liquid viagra alcohol shot in london viagra 50 mg n2   buy essays and reports help term paper   how to write a argumentive paper writings   thesis abstract how many words payroll thesis   master's thesis format literature review essays onlove   access live homework help best ehs resume   wjec english literature a level creative writing essay painting   buy viagra birmingham uk viagra beim arzt   how much does essay editing cost essay schools   essay on why it is important to be on time thesis on drugs   viagra komplett blau melatonin elderly   problem and solution essay topics contracts essay   thesis related meaning hobby on resume   narrative essay writing prompts marraige essay   research essay apa format sample coroner resume   business plan writers san diego essay + love   top homework ghostwriter websites gb resume by tammy   bachelor thesis guide utwente gad term paper   dissertation essays sentence thesis   thesis writing help paper musical resume   how to write literary essay undergrad essay   psychology case analysis example essay stage   how do you write an annotated bibliography in apa format book repo   buy a paper online bio vs resume   essay samples for kids essay elbrus   christmas satire essay thesis files   o viagra viagra india buy   drinking and driving essay research paper a1 term papers   sample thesis otherness essay   college papers to buy college essay papers essays on tv ad   how to write a good college essay step by step tsunami essays   gmo essay coursework mark   esl homework editing for hire for school bpharm resume   cialis online quick delivery fox news viagra   ellis viagra viagra album   better more effective cialis or viagra buy propecia   effects of marijuana combined with viagra dr sommer viagra   elon essay help essays on emo   anthropology research paper outline resume rehab   top 10 mfa creative writing programs 1300 word essay   how to write a formal research paper no resume   compare price for viagra 20 cialis   pay essay case study 2015   ap us history thesis rubric speech word   how do i get my email back on my ipad essay spm tips   resume help iupui resume faxing   tadalafil dosage instructions amoxil online uk   someone who can write my essay for me ut resume help   college papers purchase cdf essay   oblivion movie reviewВ parkour essays   opposite reaction to viagra original cialas   national honor society essay help essay ii with   how to send email from my iphone 6 plus resume oeuvre   resume email sample attachments 1776 essays   viagra las vegas viagra drivers   best essay ghostwriting for hire for college djs homework   wwwbuylevitra allegra viagra   viagra profesional viagra multiple   east and west cultural difference essay uvm essay   top critical essay editor services gb papers topic   reaserch work essays by ekowa   does medicare part d cover cialis viagra uae price   how do i locate my pc ip address school essay   example of research paper format climax essay   how to order levitra from canada nexium online   graduate school application essay homeworl   how to change your fortnite name ipad do math for me   buy essay not plagiarized toefl essays   essay on the importance of technology in the classroom essay quest   viagra after heart stent cialis price uk   thesis on the book of acts thesis 1 8   oregon essays tama tu essay   rough draft research paper sample essay journal   essay for class 5 in english property thesis   viagra commercial ispot viagra kosten   vicadin and viagra interaction g4 viagra   medications similar clonidine hangi cialis   resume for athletic scholarship sample ap essay   report writing tools free 911 photo essay   georgia tech essay help latin thesis   viagra kamagra jelly da ajanta pharma cialis 20 mg ndc   viagra what to expect viagra et cmu   how to write an introduction for an expository essay cuny essay exam   curriculum vitae ready made homework 9   psychology dissertation proposal resume marriage   how do i change icloud email address on my ipad apa work cited   cialis miglior prezzo online in sydney accutane za akne   phd thesis word limit buffy essays   sample resume it help desk chief information officer mandarin essay   physics homework solver essay identity   law school diversity essay examples phd thesis apa   thesis final conclusion jot essay   democracy essay topics bully essay   generic viagra prescription online viagra bristol uk   viagra like pill yo tome viagra   prednisolone what is it for viagra benefits   colleges essay examples work assignment   paper writing service reviews resume my java   esl article editing service au acts essay   argumentative essay on police brutalityВ assignments of   crestor witout prescription foros levitra   legal viagra online 250mg viagra   buy a custom research paper termpapers   introduction essay writing fvrl homework   business case study writing service essay timeline   professional thesis proofreading sites for masters cat resume   mla thesis miracle essay   cialis nitrates levitra kaufen   writing help essaye tokio   myocarditis viagra prednisone burst   que es viagra yahoo respuestas omega 3 viagra   essay models ielts nothomb resume   buy viagra quick viagra stack   summary essays thesis glossary   10 year college reunion essay resume 2009   where can i buy essays essay rubric   thesis career development sample paper of   dissertation help london lmu cds resume   viagra soft pills viagra night out   difference thesis from dissertation marking essay   viagra gell viagra in soho   writing numbers in word form hokkien essay   master thesis in economics pdf maters thesis   should i buy a business plan my essay uk   viagra reimbursement viagra 20 age   descriptive essay on winter morning found essay   how to buy cialis online in europe smurf on viagra   how viagra spray works is viagra fun   essay on music resume queries   order viagra online in south africa viagra mid 20s   popular critical essay ghostwriters service for school nsf grfp essay   pay to write research paper read speech   kitegen viagra nizagara forum   writing a report paper for essays   mla thesis outline format resume publica   said essay states a how to essay   viagra ringing in ears antabuse ritalin   essays by stephen j gould resume mha   the crucible puritan essay essay lockers   online essay help chat homework chairs   essay referencing arcada thesis   zovirax buy online overnight dr fox viagra   asssignment parshall thesis   popular definition essay ghostwriting services online vpn essay   cialis 20mg tab use viagra video   cover letter unknown receiver third man essay   efectos del viagra y el alcohol shewing viagra   viagra online safety avodart lawsuit   buy liquid tamoxifen citrate generic uk viagra   how to write code for games doctor hessayon   cheap viagra online pharmacy take cialis 20mg   term paper outline template thesis diabetes   college admission essay topics essay oulines   essays fast food restaurants thesis parts   research paper about writing democrat essay   viagra coupon viagra 4 cars   viagra alternatives injections levitra tax index   antibiotics without prescription canada valtrex neck ache   top essay writing service homework ep5ap   thesis statement examples beowulf luthers thesis   get help homework online free hp unix resume   buy cialis england wei ge viagra   how do i restore my email app on my ipad thesis basics   how to write a sales manager cover letter book excerpts   cv cover it vp resume   from puritan to yankee thesis essay on legend   creative writing dissertation titles deaf resume   research paper proposal example free essay gdp   how to buy viagra cheap proscar 5mg   buy research paper online a research   a research paper on the history of transitional services buy cheap paper   write my best phd essay on lincoln resume big 4   plendil without prescription online viagra in ibiza   cialis tablet http viagra   international business essay phd thesis qos   law dissertation topics seo resume   help on essays bacchae essay   kite runner redemption essay ob resume   low cost 5 mg cialis viagra firmeza 4   what is a double spaced essay faa atc resume   assistant retail manager resume template quotes in essay   custom mba essay ghostwriting sites usa enneagram essay   how to write out your career goals resume shirts   order viagra online music viagra   what are peer reviewed journal articles urllib2 resume   esl admission paper writer sites online tautkus resume   greek mythology thesis topics my resume for   good thesis defense questions math term paper   viagra ersatz rezeptfrei viagra with water   dans quel pays acheter viagra sans ordonnance viagra safety   orlistat 60 viagra quora   apa format in text citation for video buy best cv   who do i write my cover letter to opening essay   quality thesis meaning job resume form   science paper ideas gaston bessay   define editing news report   how to do your homework really fast essays on hero   persuasive essay template pay to do essay   sat practice essay sample it course work   viagra online no prescriptions overnight zithromax 1 gram   where can i buy tretinoin online uk cena cialisa   autumn writing paper heroic essays   buying tadalafil without a prescription cialis di medan   custom college essay service resume goa   essay english rules pulacayo thesis   picture of someone doing homework grad thesis   thesis proposal methodology example free sat essay   le viagra est il dangereux pour la sante viagra 888   gifts for dissertation writers croatian thesis   custom college presentation help resume and 401k   season summer essay the of homework   viagra blindness lawsuit viagra femenino   get cialis out of system farmaco viagra   the use of viagra for women viagra 3   journal article critique sample gre essays pdf   analysis case study examples resume lens   science research paper outline resume writenow   tadalafil 20 mg softgel viagra mk   buy valtrex canada viagra symtpms   buy-viagra-in-singapore cialis buy paypal   essay questions examples thesis body tag   find viagra free sites edinburgh cialis tubs   customer service thesis statement thesis on fraud   tretinoin cream for sale viagra bomb   apa master dissertation crusible essay   viagra generic walgreens viagra 250 mg   sales viagra uk medics viagra   public health resume samples essays suicide   business law paper hard work essay   obat singulair xenical strengths   essay writing toronto format essay   geodon achat cialis   buy viagra online genuine motilium prospect   claim for essay end of essay   essays by mark twain   pay someone to do my math homework online crear resume   can you order toporol online? viagra hawaii   viagra definition gefГјhl viagra zelf maken   case study writer jobs uk write a rubric   how to write a cover letter for a music job give assignment   essay audio examiner resume   buy ed fake propecia   television essay trend essays   how do i set up an exchange email account on my iphone chekhov essay   how to write a thesis about a book speach easy   viagra vs cialis viagra sydney   sample resume transportation driver essay meister   where to buy viagra in east london levitra nitrates   lined writing paper pdf asigment   amiloride furosemide houston propecia   generic viagra pharmacy reviews xenical kurus   english creative writing quotes resume caughran   thesis cover font essays on dare   creative writing university los angeles thesis wikihow   free essays online uk essay handout   cv writing service north london halevy thesis   police officer resume cover letter examples write a song   order cheap viagra online cheap sale viagra   sample resume for drywall installer thesis lists   text analysis essay write a torah   best article writer service essaying   military resume books resume sider   viagra excedrin lasix vs xpel   effet secondaire du viagra viagra hardon   writing services for students ml format   health essay sample eee resume   example of an abstract for dissertation thesis antenna   writing a good research report essay music rap   bayer levitra 20 mg for sale lasix in edmonton   columbia essay help greek homework   movies ratings this weekend dummett essays   cpm homework help 6th grade cv writing ppt   canadian online pharmacy cialis viagra da 25   help writing assignments homework room   online order viagra viagra viagra pen ebay   college research paper definition trades resume   essay uk writers star homework   my first time using viagra wall about flagyl   normal justification thesis buy cheap essay   movie crew spooky essays   mlk writing paper industry essay   cialis vendita on line clomid donated   thesis statement what is qa resume qtp   movies star rating shumaila resume   how to setup email on my iphone 8 plus free tutoring   azithromycin dosage for std viagra uruguaya   viagra jet stop viagra email   acheter cialis en ligne valor do cialis   sexo en nueva york samantha viagra amoxil kaina   en combien de temps le viagra agit viagra dallas   jane eyre essay prompts asian resume   computer science resume personal skills jealousy essay   can i buy viagra in canada over the counter viagra industry   viagra middle aged men cialis like pills   causes and effects of divorce thesis writings   how to write an effective articleВ essay greek   no perscription ed trial packs diflucan one dose   how to write a compare and contrast essay introduction essay on camera   song of solomon essay it resume tips   xenical buy cheap lekaren cialis   operations management assignment help shrek 2 essay   russian viagra group cialis discount   assignment writing services uk essay of stress   best resume writing services in atlanta ga essay subject   safe injection sites research papers ucc assignment   cheap viagra brisbane bcbsil viagra   financials linux oracle resume sell old essays   human rights essay speech   resume music teacher getin paper   new viagra for women viagra branding   viagra women cialis half pill   need someone to write my essay biography ideas   philosophy personal statement scary essay   new movie showtimes how to cv write   college application essay tips persusive essay   al capone does my homework tales from alcatraz hegemony essays   proofreading in microsoft word resume tamplets   cutting viagra buy levitra cheap   viagra kaufen einzeln women viagra use   best sites for english essays xp slow resume   t format cover letter examples homework thots   canibus master thesisВ aqa past essays   online pharmacies without prescription mua viagra o dau   best college application essay service best job resume   viagra plus natural ventolin que hace   how do i get messages on both my ipad and iphone essays+   generic viagra images lozenges viagra   want to buy levitra viagra clips   electric cooperative essay contest pictures resume of mcse   viagra fish levitra multiple   duke dissertations guidelines ecg thesis 2009   tips essay writing king john essay   cause and effect order essay mazin thesis   viagra with peyronie's disease siac viagra   does viagra lower your sperm count levitra tabletas   creative writing ivy tech i need a thesis   extra super cialis iau viagra   are generic viagra safe viagra baclofen   low cost cialis libidus viagra   essay project management essay rubrics   global warming essay resume composer   medical thesis writing service title ix essays   thesis paper computer science wwi essay   buy a speech sas homework   viagra price drop amoxil y cafeina   buy antibiotics online uk cialis gebruiken   essay on goals artist essays   someone who can write my essay for me kurt thesis   buying term papers cuic resume   writing haiku essay on 3es   buy cialis professional viagra de mujer   graphic design dissertation writing cv good   fake viagra deaths cialis kijiji   cialis online ireland cialis vs viagra   man power viagra natural viagra napoli   thesis on microfinance outline formats   how to write an essay on my hero diaspora essay   college essay about moving to america k thesis   biological sciences personal statement homestar resume   help with my popular persuasive essay on hillary clinton good thesis   viagra store in bangladesh cose un viagra   how to buy viagra over the counter coverage viagra   girl on viagra kamagra qartulad   homework help battle of hastings vba resume 0   cialis online america cialis hoca   woodlands junior homework help egypt auto resume   assignment essay help hp essays   anthropology thesis topics essays wiki   assignment of real estate contract no coursework   buy essay review essays abortion   sat essay 2016 write a crital   how to write an response to literature essay resume 7 habits   movie theater ratings essay attitude   active voice essays essay by jose   masters creative writing melbourne university haimson thesis   writing service websites essay tourism   book report on the report card pay for my cv   custom critical essay ghostwriters website dodgeball essay   write a good speech php assignment   hire someone to write my research paper updated resume   science research paper topics resume sap bi   essay examples about yourself for college www resume ru   resume du chapitre 1 de candide resume cpht   master thesis acknowledgement sample pdf fae resume   thesis statement great gatsby thesis steps   viagra australia website buy cialis 10mg   compare and contrast essay topics for college i write essays   viagra wie kaufen ventolin flovent   how to write a cover letter for administrative assistant jobs essayez plus   how do i mass delete emails from my iphone 7 uk riots essay   water writing paper speech website   how to find my public ip address and port subject thesis   viagra online fake zithromax wiki   higher english creative writing essay rf engg resume   sildenafil citrate generic viagra valtrex walmart   professional assignment writing service marti resume   how do i change my voicemail on iphone 6 homework hepler   generic viagra photos viagra amex   buy cheap zithromax online half viagra   prices viagra india zovirax zwanger   curriculum vitae editor service ca making essay   friendship paper laccase thesis   buy viagra gold viagra lawsuits   cialis active over the counter doxycycline lupus   marketing personal statement what case study   globalization essay questions big dig thesis   harvard thesis cover page engsci thesis   persuasive essay organizer essay fun   aol help homework student do my paper me   where can i buy essays online tech essays   sample college lab report faculty essay   pills viagra canada cialis ou kamagra   thesis statement in a narrative essay free law papers   o nome do generico do viagra buy free viagra   essay about the railway children an essay in bs   structure of the essay good reu essay   india meds direct all about viagra   essay writing abstract logging resume   patriotic essay contest resume rehab   non fiction essaysВ darden essays   uniform persuasive essay real phd thesis   how to write thankyou card thesis adhd   amitriptyline no rx cialis einfuhr   homeopathic viagra pcm pharmacy   drug abuse essay computer help   persuasive essays sample lpo resume   cialis pain penis lyrics of viagra   how to change my ip address android mba essay tips   automobile essay topics essay gane   free trial offer of viagra viagra vs ring   supervise staff resume the essayes or   csr dissertation website editing   grade essay edexcel essays   viagra grapefruitsaft viagra dispenser   gadafi da viagra sus soldados viamax viagra   how to check my ip address mac os x steele essayist   message boards on taking unprescribed clomid cialis 35 mg   100 college essays essay checks   bibtex licentiate thesis tessay france   glasgow university creative writing job write my legacy   viagra price cheap usa zovirax ebay   buy college admissions essay write esay   wallgreen viagra lasix walmart   buy viagra no rx canada viagra in kerala   doing homework on molly derrida essay   papers academic put i in resume   read descriptive essays young essays   essay my hobby dance resume agency   homework help online go hrw homework out   suhagraat ka tarika buy viagra in sa   actos without a prescription 10 vs 20 viagra   cheap drugs org pill viagra prednisone thrush   how to write a nursing research paper ed log in   resume writer minneapolis oxford essays   critical thinking university agamemnon essay   business plan writers toronto resume yurista   write my research paper online 10 essay thesis   viagra samples free valtrex cod   essay on farmer in telugu language resume for b e   exercise essay writing essays on kids   proofreading books animation essay   cu boulder resume help load db2 resume   recycling christmas wrapping paper edinburgh moodle homework   thesis paper about bullying jeff thesis   website content writing tipos de resume   new song called viva viagra apteekki viagra   mfa in creative writing online to write resume   thesis on bullying in the philippines resume pianist   professional resume writing service for teachers art essay life   thesis methodology template biology resume   literature review of project report resume templtes   best price genuine cialis activated viagra   a215 creative writing review essayez plus   writing a comparative essay conclusion english writing   example of resume objective statements for customer service song resume   how to improve leadership skills in the workplace wimp com essay   thesis calculator bdm cv resume   homework help free online chat rate this movie   students doing homework together thesis policies   global warming assignment resume faxing levitra cz   how to make busboy sound good on a resume essay exzerpt   secondary med school essay examples s essayer   accounting homework help for college students thesis delirium   viagra jet farmacocinetica role of viagra   viagra in den usa kaufen cyber viagra   essay generator power resume   viagra commercial you ve reached the age viagra 800mg   Find cheapest cialis viagra durer   help me do my statistics homework llb resume   personalised writing paper 4500 word essay   thesis topic essay of ielts   resume excellent communication skills soup and essay   re viagra cialis mg 5   popular dissertation results writer for hire gb essay or me   viagra and heart patients tomar viagra 30   viagra stories diflucan herx   abnormal psychology case study plants essay   cheap dissertation abstract proofreading services ca high term paper   dissertation writing services in pakistan uf crc resume   viagra vs cialis which is better walmart cialis   daily cialis strength prednisone heart   write essay descriptive parody resume   pocatello paper essay how to do   resume writer guru essay for fit   cost of cialis viagra works for   good ideas for research topics homework google   viagra where to buy in singapore tosh gay viagra   kindle paperwhite where to buy in singapore twain's essays   thesis help philippines page report   homework help algebra 1 sftp resume   asu creative writing club dog essay   top phd essay writing service for school plan phd thesis   auto essay writer a story essay   how to delete messages on my iphone 6 essay englisch   adult joke mr bean viagra viagra perth buy   first medicine online pharmacy review trouver cialis   how is academic writing different from other writing pathos essay   research paper malcolm x paper objective   best essay writers uk an op ed essay   report writing pay blue gold essay   age range viagra users viagra france   help to write my essay research desgn   summary essay example thesis award   uk thesis writing service ariel hessayon   personal statement academic mfa programs   sildenafil viagra 2007 viagra precios   prednisone blurred vision levitra recall   how to write a cover page for an essay term lab papers   tips for overcoming depression first resume ru   thesis statement examples teenage pregnancy write a cheq   custom descriptive essay writer website usa fms homework   short research paper a-lab   plymouth university creative writing ma essay socrates   how to write an illustrative essay resume etc   how to send email on iphone x cv text resume   how do i retrieve deleted emails on my iphone 6 giliomee thesis   research paper google docs 2 page essay   how to write numbers in an essay do essays   should you trust generic propecia from india limit viagra   essay writing services nyc computer essays   interviewing an immigrant essay socialist essay   restate thesis definition okeanos essay   custom ink business plan homework hellp   viagra real name viagra for cheap   essays on parking problems surfing essays   buy cialis 5mg online canada buy viagra mexico   list of economics thesis topics my cover letter   tips for writing an honors college essay thesis ru   purdue university application essay a resume   viagra qual Г© o melhor viagra espaa   generic. viagra jxd viagra   video viagra feminino cialis sleep   master thesis game engine typed resume   custom writing services uk ucmj essay   100mgviagra viagra gone bad   short school essay my phd study   average time to do homework in a lab   writing ipad pro vs surface 1 on 1 resume   viagra vs cialis headaches viagra in sweden   cost to hire a business plan writer thesis slavery   where to buy metformin in canada uso de viagra   benedict arnold essay rn resume jpbs   how to delete all emails from gmail on iphone 6 type my resume   term paper samples free ucl thesis   dissertation abstract example ntu usp essay   project manager cover letter writing lab   ZITHROMAX ON LINE zovirax nl   esl thesis proposal editing for hire uk bible thesis   writing your dissertation in 15 min a day lewis essays   cheap college essays for sale tufte resume   success essay essay innocence   viagra pd5 viagra price rm   result reporting in research ubc resume help   creative ghostwriters service usa suisse essayeur   online pharmacy without presciption levitra 0 5 mg   leg cramps with cialis viagra de 10 mg   what should i write for my national honor society essay how to write mr   where to buy viagra in ottawa opposite viagra   dialysis nurse sample resume essay of rizal   how to write a essay for college resume 2004   essay в английском fat homework   best homework help websites for college students resume scame   write my paragraph for me awai resume   resume by pci e pyme clear thesis   viagra para mujeres mexico cialis name   homosexuality nature or nurture essays homework child   write my school assignment thesis for bsit   write an essay on my trip to the village market aamc mcat essay   favourite festival diwali essay in hindi mba resume gpa   roy mercer viagra prednisone beer   what is a working thesis in a research paper movie opinions   buy cheap viagra generic online pfizer viagra box   Article writing thesis tables   essay writing for mba resume career   resume and server tools and games homework word   generic viagra lowest prices levitra at cvs   professional resume writers toronto write my legacy   computer and society essay sozdat resume   cytotec uterine atony viagra precoz   research paper writing services in bangalore resume exaples   interesting thing to research support resume   topic questions for essays film view   best essay introduction 44 resume tips   ways to write an essay essay for ny   generic viagra 2 day delivery cialis 5 effetti   gilgamesh essay sugarcane essay   levitra 5 mg online viagra usa jogja   uc personal statement prompt 2 help essay next day   how to write mba essays essay i pencil   greek mythology homework help essay miake   thesis and outline sample essay odyssey   out line paper eassy paper buy   warehouse resume objective statement tex phd thesis   thesis statement for diagnostic essay thesis pattern   police brutality thesis statement dessay torrents   research paper articles aia resume bank   do college essays need titles essay transfer   essay owl service dsp fpga resume   history homework help online free buyers resume   conditionnement boite de viagra lasix action   buy college entry level essay resume vasom   Obagi Tretinoin Cream 005 Buy Online viagra gegen ms   cheap viagra pill kamagra gold uk   buy get online prescription viagra viagra exercise   how to delete all emails on iphone x at once resume access   how to write chinese in yahoo mail speech address   sample business plan of internet cafe in the philippines homework ks1   united airlines seat assignment media law essay   thesis proposal about bullying towing resume   digits homework helper answer key homework image   esl paper editor services koolhaas thesis   cover letter free biotechnology resume layout c   whats works levitra cialis or viagra viagra 25mg dose   english ib world literature essay casual resume   viagra femenina como funciona viagra at 42   about disneyland essay thesis student   writing services websites essay hard work   testing new medicine to replace crestor lasix mayo clinic   buy 100mg viagra la bamba viagra   cialis vs levitra reviews viagra define   lasix without perscription splitting viagra   que es el viagra rosa viagra mit 13   viagra brand 50mg cialis knockoffs   dissertation help londonВ ptsd term paper   professional rhetorical analysis essay ghostwriters websites argument papers   topic sample essay resume oilfield   assistance with resume writing racsim essay   dissertation abstracts international section c guns essay   best websites for homework help vfw essays   essay service feedback diabetes thesis   well written essay officemax essay   short essay on gateway of india in hindi language essay nedir   effetti del cialis sul cuore alfuzosin viagra   withdrawal from abilify viagra and pills   how to change the ip address using pay for papers   personal essay outlines jet essay   order management thesis hp9000 resume   janice m krueger dissertation makea resume   essays notes scandal soar resume   cheap viagra coming soon clomid timing   help in research judge resume   technical specialist resume sample resume projects   viagra prices in usa dog viagra heart   creative writing genres list i in an essay   elsevier writing service write a bookk   thesis on beauty products essay ideas   cv writing service plymouth iium thesis   how to write an ethical essay do my poetry cv   directional and nondirectional hypothesis testing capa resume   free resume samples for government jobs baldness essay   cv cover letters essaye about   help writing college essay monomyth essay   research paper maker software revieww   opinion essay thesis statement kalДplarД essay insanity   write my dissertation mit open course   media studies case study examples essay precision   buy viagra in usa viagra eriacta   which thesis is best for a compare-and-contrast essay p shift essay   metformin no prescription viagra foie   good assignment book bio   unsw thesis font best essay 2008   cheap admission essay ghostwriter website for college buy free essay   top writing service resume tample   popular critical analysis essay writers service for school a write a cv   how t write an essay resume on soa   resume cool resume icon   buy a phd thesis resume amker   buy cialis pills online viagra young man   show me written essay write a reply   cheapest generic viagra uk viagra ipoh   buy high school diploma canada piggy essay   order of paragraphs in essay scan resume   buy orlistat prescription edsolutions247   umbrella thesis examples essay for me   cialis vendita viagra 0.58   popular critical thinking writers for hire for university paper online   lowcountry creative writing forum 101 resume   updated resume message attachments intended essay short   brainfuse live homework help santa clara holiday essays   master thesis topics in digital marketing we itemy papers   were buy viagra uk viagra que pasa   trusted cialis company overseas dapoxetine   thesis statement examples roaring twenties pms homework   buy college term papers essay revista   thesis statement examples about books resume fbi   how to write professional biography ericsson resume   help me write a thesis statement essay cotest   cialis 40 mg pills girl viagra video   compare viagra cialis and lavitra xenical en mexico   cheap business plan ghostwriting service for college design thesis   steps in writing thesis resume awesome   thesis proposal on tourism in nepal the resume com   avoid grapefruit viagra strattera online   cialis sin receta us clomid que es   technical resume writing services acid essay   insurance birth control viagra levitra se uzima   viagra high altitude drunk viagra   martin luther king dissertation resume twitter   thesis statement claim of fact bear essays   thesis editing services dublin homework stats   hire someone to write my thesis assignment film   free lawn service business plan mscs thesis   prix viagra generique pharmacie viagra in vienna   winning cover letters sophea resume   buy essays online reviews said phd thesis   top cover letter proofreading sites au resume rater   stanford intellectual vitality essay tips resume names   christopher columbus thesis statement elisa essay   critical thinking attributes taliban essay   trusted online pharmacy cialis diflucan quebec   master thesis proposal example ppt sullys resume   earthquake essays essay on iago   essay writing basics viper resume   writing law essays essay quoting   thesis checker online free toyota essay   best price for xenical ampicillin dosing   how to write birthday cards to a friend write my bio   how do i change my email password on my iphone ios 11 slpa resume   custom assignment writers service au essays tests   help writing popular college essay on hillary homework pens   cheap dissertation conclusion ghostwriters site for college dessay italian   jhu essay help write a resume   critical thingkingВ crical   viagra in gatorade prank pas viagra   how to write a commentary essay thesis ppt font   pumkin pie and viagra pub viagra vieux   viagra femenino en farmacias de argentina chemical viagra   buy paper lamp shades online india resume teens   supremesuppliers dosis de cialis   acheter cialis en ligne canada viagra and luvox   thesis statement powerpoint high school free apa online   thesis binding ohio state university trees essay   help to write research paper our earth essay   how do you write a comparison essay essay paper   it fresher resume samples homework a   writing service manuals can sleep   viagra in chemists dapoxetine on nhs   viagra plavix cialis lipitor synthroid levitra propecia nhs viagra rules   canada viagra good morning ii video enhance cialis   writing service online vennskap essay   how do i save an email on my ipad mini   creative writing level 2 new courseworks   pay for essays online homework death   where to buy nexium 40 mg propranolol xanax   writing services slu resume midwife   acknowledgement page thesis resume mri   professional annotated bibliography ghostwriting websites for phd lilou thesis   design thesis synopsis write a gigue   viagra side effects on blood pressure buy cialis amazon   where can i get viagra cialis itusozluk   xenical 120 mg to buy online cialis es bueno   essay sample yourself essayes de   popular personal statement proofreading websites for university jewelry resume   writing an essay helpВ resume headshot   great love essay sasktel resume   re write my paper essays on poems   levitra online us pharmacy zithromax cures   second best to viagra tomar viagra 18   buy viagra online pfizer viagra how long   law dissertation ngo resume   how to write a basic essay term paper form   report writing buy 131 essay   best custom essay writing services grel resume   buy viagra bangalore nina viagra   what is better viagra or kamagra viagra en calama   websites that write essays resume of dba   cheap writing help communist essay   ivy league dissertation editing essays for buy   buy Generic Cialis (Tadalafil) 20mg viagra pkv   research paper writing pdf dawes act essay   ability to think advanced essay   admission essay write a tribute   brand viagra shipped overnight from usa viagra inhibits   general essay writings in in telugu ouac essay   uf creative writing program fast foof essay   architecture topics essay thesis slavery   buy depade cipro warnings   common app transfer essay engine resume   education business plan sample biography book   professional expository essay writer website for university jfk term papers   best essay help bankpro resume   thesis essay example resume of iim   viagra international shipping japan o q e levitra   essay writing service craigslist resume buildeer   paper writing company passage essay   planning research paper write a reciept   develop your leadership skills by john adair do my papewr   thesis proposal example apa format resume chief   pleasure and disquietude essay room 101 essays   why can't i write my essay the shawl essay   how to write a introduction paragraph for a essay dubois essay   composition vs creative writing movieratings   certified canadian pharmacy viagra viagra roots   image registration thesis g courses   thesis statement examples research punkty resume   assignment outline example usf essay 2014   viagra 50 mg tab levitra action   pfizer viagra on line viagra hard sell   literature review service homework myth   custom term papers 7 95 tyler resume   dth viagra viagra buy japan   how to prepare essay writing for ssc cgl essay film   rate my essay paper cco resume   i don't wanna do my homework homework 2 svcd   essay online recharge l e d essay   order viagra in australia viagra mg doses   essay examples word write a perl   doxycycline order   proofreading drafts resume 1st job   biology homework helpers homework helpers career press in my resume   viagra tv advertising cialis spray   guide to write poems essays   pen pals creative writing group athens essay   english writing help dbq essay help   oracle pl sql on error resume next no homework   where to purchase viagra cialis levitra viagra on women   buy brand name viagra levitra deluje   operation management assignment liaison resume   best reumes m b a on resume   antigone paper john jay essay   book reports for sale matrimony essay   viagra and high altitude viagra opiates  
The blog of the book, Pain, Pleasure and Perversity: Discourses of Suffering in Seventeenth-Century England